Car rental in New Town (Key West)
Search hundreds of travel sites at once for car rental deals in New Town
Save up to 48%Compare multiple travel sites with one search.
Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees.
Filter your dealsFilter by car type, brand and more. Instantly customize your results.
Book with flexibilityUse our "free cancellation" filter for maximum flexibility at no extra cost.
Cheap car rentals in New Town (Key West)
| Economy | C$ 95/day |
| Compact | C$ 98/day |
| Intermediate | C$ 97/day |
| Standard | C$ 80/day |
| Full-size | C$ 100/day |
| Minivan | C$ 127/day |
| Full-size SUV | C$ 126/day |
| Premium | C$ 144/day |
| Luxury | C$ 118/day |
| Convertible | C$ 131/day |
| Pick-up truck | C$ 108/day |
| Premium SUV | C$ 140/day |
| Standard SUV | C$ 105/day |
| Intermediate SUV | C$ 108/day |
New Town (Key West) car rental reviews and directory
Thrifty
7.3
Good
36 reviewsCleanliness
7.5
Comfort
7.5
Pick-up/Drop-off
7.3
Value for money
7.2
One location in New Town
Filters
Reviews
10.0 Wonderful
May 2021
Pros:
Staff was helpful and friendly and drop off was super easy.Cons:
All was good.8.8 Very good
Sep. 2020
Pros:
Pretty simple in & out. Toll policy so-so.Cons:
Car wasn't ready for pickup at my allotted time.6.0 Okay
Aug. 2020
Pros:
The staff was helpful at check-in and check-out.Cons:
The air conditioner was not that great in the daytime heat and the gas tank was not full on pickup.2.0 Poor
Aug. 2020
Pros:
I was unable to cancel my rental. Plans changed due to COVID-19Cons:
I was unable to cancel my rental. Plans changed due to COVID-196.0 Okay
Mar. 2020
Pros:
Didn't get to take the tripCons:
Didn't get a refund for the auto insurance after my trip was cancelled.10.0 Wonderful
Mar. 2020
Cons:
cheaper ratesEnterprise Rent-A-Car
6.6
Okay
31 reviewsCleanliness
7.0
Comfort
7.5
Pick-up/Drop-off
6.5
Value for money
6.5
2 locations in New Town
Filters
Reviews
8.0 Very good
Feb. 2024
4.0 Mediocre
Apr. 2021
Pros:
Drop off was easyCons:
The car was filthy and rattling. Ripped up seats in the back..... and the desk guy in key west was so rude and non helpful8.0 Very good
Apr. 2021
Pros:
The drop off was fine!Cons:
We had a 10am airport car pickup at Key West International Airport. No cars were available at 9:50am when we arrived. We had to wait until 10:30am for next car coming back to be washed and cleaned. No one asked about Sun Pass. Will have to pay a fortune for each toll we went through without Sun Pass on the car?2.0 Poor
Mar. 2021
Pros:
Nice vehicle.Cons:
Arrived at the pickup time. They were closed. Came back the next day to get the vehicle, it wasn't ready. After an hour long wait, the vehicle was presented to me. Clearly it was rushed. Did not have a full tank of gas. There was no walk around to inspect the vehicle. I took off with the vehicle. Already late for my meeting. Upon drop off in Miami, I was informed that there was damage to the vehicle on the passenger side rear door. Since it was a black vehicle and on the passenger side, I did not notice it on pickup. So in Miami I was informed that I will be charged for the damage.4.0 Mediocre
Feb. 2021
Pros:
Reserved a full size sedan in Key West. Only available was a compact. Had no choice and told it was an upgrade. Could not debate as that was the only car available. I took out collision when reserved with Kayak which also covered 2nd driver. I was told that would not give me coverage and second driver had additional charge. I ended up paying twice the amount I locked in on with my reservation. Very disappointed in Enterprise.2.0 Poor
Nov. 2020
Pros:
NothingCons:
EverythingHertz
6.0
Okay
72 reviewsCleanliness
6.6
Comfort
6.5
Pick-up/Drop-off
5.7
Value for money
5.9
One location in New Town
Filters
Reviews
2.0 Poor
Oct. 2023
8.0 Very good
Oct. 2022
2.0 Poor
Nov. 2021
1.9 Poor
Jul. 2021
6.0 Okay
Apr. 2021
Pros:
The women at the counter was amazing. She was a true professional under extreme stress. There were no.cars avafor.pick up and people were very upset.Cons:
Not waiting for well over an hour for my rental.2.0 Poor
Apr. 2021
Pros:
The customer service ruined my entire experience.Cons:
The Hertz representative could have treated me like a humanAlamo
6.9
Okay
27 reviewsCleanliness
7.4
Comfort
7.4
Pick-up/Drop-off
6.4
Value for money
7.2
One location in New Town
Filters
Reviews
2.0 Poor
May 2021
Pros:
Staff was reluctant to help. arrived at pickup and was told cara wouldn’t be ready for another 2 hours.. which was 4 hours over our original pickup time. Stranded at an airport waiting for our car.10.0 Wonderful
Apr. 2021
Pros:
everything went smoothly, from booking to returnCons:
price can always be better, but in this case Alamo was the best price.2.0 Poor
Apr. 2021
Pros:
N/ACons:
Didn’t have my rental car available @ time of pick-up. Had to cancel4.0 Mediocre
Apr. 2021
Pros:
Complimentary upgrade because my vehicle was unavailableCons:
Car was not available upon pickup. Was told three hour wait but did not get called for seven hours. Car was dirty and windows needed to be cleaned from all the previous dirt and grim. Customer service disconnected my call six times while trying to remedy the problem2.0 Poor
Apr. 2021
Pros:
Friendly staffCons:
Car was not what I reserved. They had no full size cars available. Car smelled like smoke and made my kids sick2.0 Poor
Jan. 2021
Pros:
The convenience is good because it's a small airport.Cons:
They never give you the car you reservedNational
2.0
Poor
1 reviewCleanliness
2.0
Comfort
6.0
Pick-up/Drop-off
2.0
Value for money
2.0
One location in New Town
Filters
Reviews
2.0 Poor
Jan. 2021
Pros:
The car was niceCons:
We had a reservation for 9AM to drive from Key West to Miami. The car was not ready for us to drive away until noon!! When we checked in, the attendant said the car would be ready in an hour, but really took three hours. By the time we left there were 150 people in line waiting to check in to pick up their rental. Airplanes continued to arrive throughout the period with people expecting to pick up a car and continue their journey. Airport security was having a fit trying to make people maintain social distance when the airport physically did not contain enough space to allow 150 people in line waiting and people arriving claiming their bags on the baggage carousel to maintain distinace. The entire problem was caused by National, Enterprise, Alamo car rental mismanagement and inability to think outside the box. In fact, I watched two employees show up to work then disappear when having to confront unhappy customers looking for an explanation for why they couldn’t get their car.Ace
5.7
Fair
No reviews available
One location in New Town
Economy Rent a Car
5.6
Fair
No reviews available
One location in New Town
Sunnycars
No score available yet
2 locations in New Town
Ace Rental Cars
No score available yet
One location in New Town
Free2Move
No score available yet
One location in New Town
VIPCars Recommendation
No score available yet
One location in New Town
Car rental locations in or near New Town (Key West)
Good to know
Most popular agency | Budget |
|---|---|
Most popular car type | Convertible |
Average price | C$ 110/day |
Good deal | C$ 109/day |
When to book a rental car in New Town, Key West
Top tips for renting a car in New Town, Key West
- 25% of our users found rental cars in New Town for C$ 109 or less.
- Book your rental car in New Town at least 2 days before your trip in order to get a below-average price.
- Economy rental cars in New Town are around 53% cheaper than other car types, on average.
- April is typically the cheapest month to rent a car in New Town, with prices around C$ 78/day. December, in contrast, is often the most costly month, with an average of C$ 112/day.
- If you’re looking to save money and don’t mind renting a car in another neighborhood in Key West, look for deals in Mid Town East, where daily prices are around C$ 87/day.
FAQs about renting a car in New Town (Key West)
How much does it cost to rent a car in New Town?
On average a rental car in New Town costs C$ 110 per day.
Are car rentals cheaper in other Key West neighborhoods?
No. Based on our information, DOLLAR in New Town is the cheapest car rental location in Key West.
What is the cheapest car rental company in New Town?
In the past 72 hours, the cheapest rental car price (C$ 55/day) in New Town was found at DOLLAR, 3495 S Roosevelt Blvd.
What is the best rental car company in New Town?
Based on ratings and reviews from real users on KAYAK, the best car rental company in New Town is BUDGET (5.6, 36 reviews).
How can I find car rentals near me in New Town?
Take a look at our extensive car rental location map to find the best rental cars near you.
What is the most popular rental car type in New Town?
Convertible (Ford Mustang Convertible or similar) is the most frequently booked rental car type in New Town.
How much does a Convertible car rental cost in New Town?
A Convertible car rental in New Town costs C$ 120 per day, on average.
How much does it cost to rent a car for a week in New Town?
On average a rental car in New Town costs C$ 772 per week (C$ 110 per day).
How much does it cost to rent a car long term for a month in New Town?
On average a rental car in New Town costs C$ 3,309 per month (C$ 110 per day).