Shelter Island Heights hotels

Shelter Island Heights hotels

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Heights, NY, United States
Check-in
Check-out
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Good to know

Low Season October
High Season September
  Average price (weeknight): C$ 259
  Average price (weekend night): C$ 532

cheapest month to stay

12%

expected price decrease

most expensive time to stay

35%

expected price increase

(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Sun. - Thu.

(weeknight)

(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Fri. & Sat.

(weekend night)

Where to stay in Shelter Island Heights?

Our Heatmaps tool will help you find the perfect place to stay in Shelter Island Heights by showing you how close hotel options are to major activities

Best Shelter Island Heights hotels

Show all
Seven - Shelter Island Guest House - Shelter Island Heights - Bedroom
1
9.8 Excellent (99 reviews)
C$ 434+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at SEVEN - Shelter Island Guest House in Shelter Island Heights, you'll be next to a golf course, within a 10-minute walk of Shelter Island Country Club and Crescent Beach. Featured amenities include a 24-hour business center, express check-in, and express check-out. Planning an event in Shelter Island Heights? This bed & breakfast has facilities measuring 20 square feet (2 square meters), including a meeting room. Guests may use a ferry terminal shuttle for a surcharge, and free self parking is available onsite.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: The photos showed that it looked as if it was located on the water.
Cons: I thought the breakfast should have been much heartier and various.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Every thing was absolutly perfect : the house, the location, the service and of course but not least the hostess. We really enjoiyed our stay and were sad to have to leave !!
Cons: We had to leave !!!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: A wonderful place for a wonderful stay! I was looking for a solo getaway, and Beth and Christina made my whole week at Seven exactly what I wanted - rest, relaxation, & recreation. A great balance of winding down on the beach and getting some hiking and biking in. If you're looking for a great B&B experience on SI, Seven is it. Will definitely be back!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: We loved a lot about this place. The location was perfect for us--we were able to walk to dinner (a few different restaurants), the beach, and live music. They had bikes for our use that enabled us to explore the island--they were so helpful in assisting us planing our route. The breakfast was delicious and healthy--the freshest fruits, jams, breads, oatmeal, croissants, etc. (yum!) There was a front porch and back porch where we enjoyed our breakfast, and afternoon tea. We will definitely be back.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: I know Shelter Island well and I chose this property because of its location - it's perfect! The property is immaculately clean throughout. The kitchen was well appointed and very welcoming... everything one needs is there and is set up so you feel very much "at home". The art throughout the premises is striking and in very good taste. My bedroom was not large but very thoughtfully laid out and had everything I needed. The bed was very comfortable with very good linens. The bathroom very attractive and had all amenities; towels are thick and plentiful.
Cons: I had reserved a Queen room but the bed was actually a double. If I had been traveling with my partner, might have been a bit uncomfortable but it was fine for me.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Very clean and comfortable. Lovely art work and interesting books.
Cons: Would have liked a swimming pool but plenty of lovely beaches nearby with beach towels, chairs, and umbrellas provided by the B&B.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The breakfast was wonderful. The staff was so kind and accommodating. The amenities were so great - from the beach towels to the bikes, to beach chairs, etc. We loved everything about our stay and will not plan on staying anywhere else ever again on Shelter Island!
Cons: Nothing could be better! Everything was the best.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: From the minute we arrived the detail in the presentation of this property and the welcome we received was outstanding. Often it's the little things that make the difference and at Seven, Beth and her team excel. We were provided an extensive list of things to do places to visit and restaurants to enjoy. All of the recommendations proved to be exactly as described. We took the LIRR to Greenport and chose to hire a car (Hertz) to get around which was ideal as taxis on the island can be expensive. If it's in the height of summer there are beaches and restaurants within walking distance but the weather was pretty inclement during our stay so the car was a must. Just a tip, the Hertz "Office" is a small desk inside the Greenporter Motel and the agent arrives at the time you have booked your car (so it's not manned all the time). It's a tiny operation but very convenient. Shelter Island is a very special place and would we return? Most definitely.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: We opted for a few days away from NYC following a friend's wedding. We had no clue where to pick but Seven looked lovely from the photos. And it was superb. Excellent customer service, a clean and quiet room, and a delicious breakfast each day. It's a perfect location for easy access to beaches and restaurants nearby and further afield. We even hired bikes and used them to go out for dinner. All the staff were very friendly but especially Beth made us feel very at home and nothing was too much trouble for her. Seven is a relaxed home away from home and we shall be returning as soon as we can. And Evie (the weimaraner) was a treasure - she melted our hearts. Thank you again for a wonderful stay.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everything is exceptional and amazing. This is the only place I'll ever stay on Shelter Island. Every time I stay here, this place exceeds my expectations! Beth, the host and owner, and everyone else who works there are just magnificent.
Cons: Everything was PERFECT.
Wickham-Prince Bed And Breakfast - Southold - Building
2
9.7 Excellent (44 reviews)
C$ 369+
Overview Reviews
The Wickham-Prince Bed and Breakfast offers luxury accommodations in an historic home in Southold, New York. Southold is centrally located on the North Fork of Long Island, an area known for it's coastal beauty and wineries. Wickham-Prince offers two bedrooms with en-suite bathrooms that includes toiletries, bathrobes and a hairdryer. Each room also includes a flat screen TV, cable and free Wi-Fi. The first floor of the house has a common room for breakfast and relaxing. Guests have access to a shared patio and garden. The house has central air conditioning. The center of Southold is less than a block away. Beaches and vineyards are within 5 minutes.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The service was exceptional. The breakfast was wonderful and filled me up all day. The location was centrally located so we were able to visit the local beaches and local attractions with no trouble. The hostess was always so helpful and knowledgeable about the area. I would not hesitate at all to stay here again.
Cons: Nothing, everything was perfect.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everything was lovely. Room was cozy and very comfortable. Had everything we needed. Sue was so friendly and her breakfast is delicious.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The location is excellent with vineyards, beaches and restaurants within walking distance. Sue makes a wonderful breakfast that exceeded my expectation! Sue and Doug were very welcoming and went above and beyond to ensure we enjoyed our stay. We will definitely stay here again!
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Sue was super friendly and she makes a mean breakfast!! We had a great time!
Cons: The bed was too soft (my preference) and I needed a second soft pillow, my head felt lower than my feet.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Exceptional service and delicious food!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Yes everything was excellent
Cons: Everything
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Yummy homemade scones and blueberry compote.
Cons: Nothing
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The accommodations were wonderful! Sue and Doug were great and the breakfast was delicious! We will definitely be coming to stay again!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Sue and her husband were extremely welcoming and went above and beyond making sure our needs were met! From the quaint warm vibe, to welcoming/clean rooms and wonderful tailored breakfasts; this is a B&B we will stay in many times more over the years!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The room, bed, bathroom and linens were all luxurious and very comfortable and the hosts were helpful and friendly, yet unobtrusive. And the breakfasts far exceeded my expectations! We will definitely stay here again!
Cons: Nothing! All was great!
The Harborfront Inn - Greenport - Building
3
9.2 Excellent (375 reviews)
C$ 368+
Overview Reviews
Offering a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness centre, The Harborfront Inn is centrally located near the shops and restaurants in Greenport. Free WiFi access is available. A flat-screen cable TV and refrigerator are included in each guest room. The private bathrooms are equipped with a hairdryer and a bathrobe. A balcony is available for certain room types. A 24-hour front desk is available at the Greenport Harborfront Inn. Vending machines provide snacks and refreshments. North Ferry Terminal is just 3 minutes’ walk from the property. Kontokosta Winery is 3 minutes’ drive.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Quiet,pool,water view,friendly staff,no need to bother anyone everything was well organized.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Cleanliness and location.
10.0 Excellent
Cons: Convenient location. Very gracious staff.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Breakfast was great clean rooms
9.6 Excellent
Pros: The location is fabulous and it was extremely clean. Staff was very accommodating
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Staff was so nice, friendly and professional. Perfect location.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: The beds were very comfortable the room was clean
Cons: The smell of the garbage while relaxing by the pool
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Mattress was a little too firm. But the staff, accommodations, views were excellent.
Cons: White towels although clean appeared to be a little dingy.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The location and nice room
Cons: The air was loud
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Wonderful location with amazing harbor views!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Easy to navigate, clean, friendly staff, great location and reasonable price
Cons: All good
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Great place. Loved it. Fantastic shower!
Cons: Breakfast needed to be replenished. Almost nothing left when we arrived.
Stirling House Bed & Breakfast - Greenport - Building
4
9.7 Excellent (30 reviews)
C$ 366+
Overview Reviews
Located in Greenport, Stirling House Bed & Breakfast is on the waterfront, within a 15-minute walk of East End Seaport Maritime Museum and Railroad Museum of Long Island. Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby and luggage storage. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Close to Main Street for all the Sights, Shops and Restaurants no need to drive at all
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The host Clay welcomes you right away when you arrive and after talking with him for a minute ,You feel like you know him! He's a awesome baker with a,sweet homemade breakfast on his porch facing the water. Just a one night stay for me and my husband. But we will defintley be back.☺☺ Thank you Clay The Weingartens
Cons: There was nothing not to like. Beautiful place☺just Fabulous!!!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everything perfect
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Very close to downtown and the Breakfast was awesome!!!
Cons: Nothing!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Owner was wonderful and helpful
Cons: Nothing, it was great
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The location is overlooking a small bay and a short walk to town. The breakfasts were delicious and filling. The room was big and bed was comfortable.
Cons: Having to leave
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everything was perfect and Clay was an unbelievable host. His breakfast is out of this world delicious all while admiring the waterfront view while seated on the front patio. He also gave great tips on places to go see and eat. We will definitely be back again!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Lovely B&B with every detail for comfort met. Clay makes an amazing breakfast and gives pointers for places to eat and see. Would definitely go back!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Great location, quite street but steps away from restaurants and shops. Clay's breakfast's were delicious and he made you comfortable at his property. I lost a ring in the room and he made every effort to find it and mail it to me.
Cons: Nothing
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Place was perfect for a weekend jaunt to wineries and greenport
Shorecrest Bed and Breakfast - Southold - Building
5
9.2 Excellent (59 reviews)
C$ 387+
Overview Reviews
When you stay at Shorecrest Bed and Breakfast in Southold, you'll be by the ocean, within a 5-minute drive of Sparkling Pointe and The Old Field Vineyards. Featured amenities include a library and coffee/tea in a common area. Free self parking is available onsite.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Perfect breakfast, perfect bed, very nice host! What else?
Cons: Nothing. Just be aware that the B&B is on the North Fork, which is very worth it!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: It was clean, comfortable and the breakfast was amazing.
Cons: The shower could use a better shower head.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: The room was very clean and comfortable. Breakfast was a pleasant surprise. Not your run of the mill bnb!
Cons: The road noise is a bit annoying but isn't an issue once inside. The door lock being over 100 years old can take some getting used to, but adds to the charm of the building.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Amazing bed and breakfast. Food was spectacular. Location was perfect. Very nice trip when you use the fairy to orient point.
Cons: No complaints. Everything was perfect.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The house was beautiful and the gardens were amazing. Marilyn was a great host and the breakfast was wonderful. Very relaxing.
Cons: The room got a little warm during the night.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Interesting decoration in the house , nice garden , breakfast delicious with homemade kishes every day , warm atmosphere
Cons: Nothing
7.9 Good
Pros: Great location, interesting house
Cons: Breakfast only at 9 so if you traveling it’s way to late and we missed out
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Very nice and relaxing time. Marylin made us feel welcome. Breakfast was terrific. Would recommend to others looking for a nice weekend getaway on eastern LI.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: We were there for a family wedding nearby. It was a lovely “century home” with English gardens and a gracious host Marilyn. The room was lovely and comfortable, and the breakfasts were sumptuous! The atmosphere was very calming and relaxed. The location is within 5 minutes of central Greenport and many vineyards and eating establishments.
The Chequit - Shelter Island Heights - Bedroom
6
8.9 Excellent (153 reviews)
C$ 328+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at The Chequit Inn in Shelter Island Heights (The Heights), you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Shelter Island Country Club and Sylvester Manor. Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby, luggage storage, and coffee/tea in a common area. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Great rooms and adequately sized private restrooms. Cozy and relaxed atmosphere. Staff was beyond helpful and customer service friendly. Location was amazing.
Cons: Nothing! Everything was perfect !
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Loved the porch!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Close location to the North Ferry, 5 minute drive to Sunset/Crescent Beach. Very clean and modern, minimalist style in rooms. Delicious, complimentary breakfast in the parlor with healthy choices. Lovely, outdoor sitting porch overlooking main road and bay. Renovations maintained the charming and original character of the hotel.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Lovely breakfast and coffee, evening drinks on the terrace. Beautifully appointed room.
Cons: Room 2 was noisy at times and had no view, but the room itself was nice
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Great place to stay on Shelter Island! Nice renovated rooms, but still with a bed and breakfast feel.
Cons: Nothing.
6.3 Good
Pros: Great location, beautiful porch
Cons: No mention in any of their pre arrival communications that they were in off season and many restaurants still not open full schedule. No front desk staff on duty after 6 on weekdays. For rates charging in off season could use some refurbishing, inn needs an exterior paint job, stains on porch furniture. Room needed a fresh coat of paint.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Very chic and quaint.
Cons: No TV.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The location and view of the harbor.
7.5 Good
Pros: Comfortable bed, nice porch, convenient location.
Cons: Room was spartan, no dresser or television.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: It was charming. Southern charm feel and instagramable for sure
Cons: Wish they were on the beach
8.8 Excellent
Cons: One night price was a little high.
A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast - Southold - Building
7
9.1 Excellent (42 reviews)
C$ 399+
Overview Reviews
Relax on the large wrap-around front porch of this Long Island, New York bed and breakfast. Free Wi-Fi and daily breakfast are offered. Cedar Beach is 1 mile away. Each uniquely styled room at A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast features en suite bathroom. Decorated with antique accents, these rooms include a seating area. Complimentary bicycles and beach chairs are available at A Walk in the Woods B&B. There is also a living room with fireplace. This estate is located directly on the 14 mile Bayview bicycle loop. Pindar Vineyards is 5 miles away.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Charm & quietness of the house and surroundings were very relaxing. Enjoyed our visit along with the proximity to our friends house that we were visiting with.
Cons: Low shower head :-), I'm tall. Was a little warm sleeping, probably could have opened the windows.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: OWNERSHIP, 3 GENERATIONS, KIND, PROFESSIONAL, GREAT ADVICE ABOUT LOCAL WINERIES, SEAFOOD, ETC. QUIET, WILDLIFE RIGHT NEARBY, SECLUDED, SECURE, AUTHENTIC, IMMACULATE, A GEM! SELFISHLY, I WISH I COULD KEEP IT A SECRETE, BUT IT WOULDN'T BE FAIR TO THESE 3 LADIES.
Cons: NOTHING. PERFECTION. IF U R A HEAD BANGER, ATTENTION SEEKING NARCISSIST GO TO THE HAMPTONS
10.0 Excellent
Cons: I would have liked if we could have stayed longer. Our hosts, Flo and Janine, were warm, friendly women. From our first meeting, we felt we had known them forever; that they were friends. The location was true to its name: "A Walk in the Woods"...our closest neighbors being a gaggle? of turkeys and Monty, the resident horse. I think I have his name correct; sorry Monty if I am wrong. We spent quite a bit of time on the wraparound porch, relaxing in any of several wicker chairs.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: This is an incredible place hidden off the road. The house and grounds are spectacular. There is such attention to detail in both the decorating and service. Our room - the vintage rose suite- was bigger than our apartment! Flo and her daughter Janine were excellent hosts and made us feel so welcome. Will definitely be back!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Every aspect of the stay was above expectations
Cons: Nothing
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The B&B was such a peaceful and relaxing place. The room provided amenities beyond any hotel room, had a private bathroom and was very comfortable. Flo and Janie were very friendly and helpful with direction and things to do in the area.
Cons: There isn’t a sign at the turn off for the B&B. Even with our GPS we weren’t sure it was the right road until we were 500 ft up the road.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Quite, great hosts
Cons: Terrible internet connection, it is not acceptable for today’s standard
7.5 Good
Pros: The grounds were very well kept and pleasant
7.9 Good
Pros: Breakfast was good. The B&B was spotless. Beds very comfortable. Very nice front porch. The B&B was very vintage. The host was very friendly and very helpful.
Cons: The location was in the middle of nowhere. Very hard to find. B&B was located on a private dirt road. There should be a sign where you have to turn and a sign to get into the B&B.
Overview Reviews
The Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport hotel is located just a half mile from the MacArthur Airport and is in the heart of the Ronkonkoma, Bohemia, and Western Suffolk business districts of New York. Our complimentary airport shuttle is also available to drive guests to the nearby Long Island Railroad station, offering direct access to New York City's Penn Station. Take advantage of our central location to travel east to the Tanger Outlets in Riverhead, the Long Island Vineyards, and the Hamptons or travel only three miles to the Fire Island ferries. The Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport hotel offers deluxe accommodations, friendly service and a relaxed atmosphere that awaits our guests. Certain to please the busy executive or leisure traveler, our rooms and suites are well appointed with a variety of amenities including a 27'' television, complimentary high-speed Internet access, two dual-line phones with data port and voicemail, and the Hilton Clock Radio which provides a mini-plug for your MP3 Player. Our large desks make working on the road easier with desk level outlets and ergonomic chair. Each room also offers a refrigerator and microwave, as well as an iron and ironing board. Travelers at the Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport hotel are sure to enjoy the On Command video, TV video games, complimentary HBO and USA Today each weekday morning. At the Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport hotel, enjoy a brisk workout in our on-site fitness center, take a swim in the indoor heated swimming pool or relax in our whirlpool. We also offer complimentary access to our business center 24-hours a day. Relax and unwind from the day's events in our Pavilion Lounge. The Great American Grill features our cooked-to-order full American breakfast buffet daily and a relaxed dinner menu nightly. ***** Everything. Right where you need it. *****
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Spacious
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Staff
Cons: Price
4.2 Okay
Pros: Location
Cons: I got charged for extra breakfasts and no one there is addressing this issue.
7.9 Good
Pros: Alex was nice and professional....place very clean....
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Very clean. Close to everything
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Clean. Staff most helpful Room spacious clean Bed's very comfy
Cons: Need more carts for luggage
9.6 Excellent
Pros: The staff are amazing...Assistant Manager, Thomas went out of the way to accommodate any requests and in general every staff was extremely courteous and welcoming. They were always available to assist with any queries or information. The great convenience is that they can arrange free of cost shuttle/uber if your office is nearby the hotel
Cons: Nothing as such. Everything was good!
7.5 Good
Pros: Location
Cons: Check in was 3pm we didn't get our room till 4pm
7.5 Good
Pros: only drank coffee,
Cons: they charged me twice for my stay, still trying to get my refund. this whole process of paying the property ahead of time has been a real cluster fock
3.3 Mediocre
Cons: The room was stinky, too dark and some pillowcases and towels didn´t seem to be clean. I didn´t really feel comfortable throughout the stay. The foyer and breakfast area was okay but nothing special; all in all I am quite disappointed and expected something different from a Hilton Garden Inn.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Clean property & great staff
5.0 Okay
Pros: Took ish 40 minutes to get into room No crowds at all Delays because NO Carts*** for luggage Our room key did not work Took 3 truhe's. Staff had to come to open Finally
Cons: The worse check in experience My husband has heart condition Needed cart Needed to get into room he was tired as I was Really great staff had to carry by hand our luggage After. 40 mins to get in our room
Sound View Greenport - Greenport - Building
9
8.5 Excellent (235 reviews)
C$ 384+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Sound View Greenport in Greenport, you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Kontokosta Winery and 67 Steps Beach. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Event facilities at this hotel consist of conference space and a meeting room. Free self parking is available onsite.
8.8 Excellent
Pros: The hotel has magnificent views of Long Island Sound. The restaurant on premises called the Halyard serves very good food. Loved the sounds of the water. We were lulled to sleep each night.
Cons: The shower did not have good water pressure. The fitness room needs better equipment. The room was a little tight.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Beautifully renovated, amazing seafront location, great staff, and also very nice restaurant.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The room was well laid out, bed extremely comfortable, niceties a nice and well enjoyed surprise and the shower was amazing! My husband and I enjoyed sitting on the deck enjoying the sounds of the Sound’s waves lapping up on the shore right in front of us. We loved watching the Sun set. So beautiful!
Cons: The fact that our vacation was too short and we had to leave.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: It’s on the ocean and the view is amazing and the sunset and morning here is very beautiful!! Must be here !!!!
Cons: If you close the bathroom door it’s not going to be opened from outside,that’s the only I think has to be fixed.
7.9 Good
Pros: Great beach views from your room, all rooms have a lovely porch where you can read and enjoy a glass of wine. The rooms are clean and very comfortable beds. They renovated the property, so everything is new and bright.
Cons: The hotel is located near the road, so you will hear traffic noises in your room. It didn't bother use too much, but if you are sensitive to noise it can be an issue. Also, they need to improve the shades, it was still very light in our room during night because of the outdoor lighting.
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Rooms were fully refurbished and beds were comfortable. It would have nice to have a throw rug on the floor as was pictured on web site. Yoga in the morning was a nice touch but they should have had water in the yoga room. A little over priced but the location was excellent, I would go back
Cons: When it rained water flowed in the back door. We had to shove towels under the door.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The view.... Bathrooms Balcony Nice touch with free cookies and sparkling water in room
Cons: For us mattress was a little too soft. We weren't crazy about the restaurant
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Water view was beautiful. Restaurant delicious!
7.1 Good
Pros: View was terrific. Bed was comfortable.
Cons: Breakfast mediocre, no hot water in shower when we arrived. Place looked dated and was overpriced.
7.9 Good
Pros: The view of the see and sunset; nice room, well renovated and private balcony; comfy beds alrhough the sleeping sofa squeeked at every mo ve; good pool; nice restaurant with good food; Surroundings: Greenport is lovely with a relaxed atmosphere; we took the short ferry ride to Shelter Island and then to Sag Harbour and went all the way took to Montauk - a really nice day out.
Cons: - The hotel is located close to the road, so you hear the cars all the time (although there is not much traffic at night). - Breakfast is complementary but has really limited choice. Coffee is good. - More chairs for the beach would be recommended. Some guests had a common but annoying habit of quickly reserving their space in the morning by putting a towel on the chairs but rhen not using the chairs until much later. - -
Overview Reviews
The Courtyard Long Island hotel is centrally located between the Long Island Expressway and the MacArthur Airport, offering complimentary airport shuttle service from 7am-11pm, and hotel-wide WiFi. Our hotel offers large rooms that feature a sleeper sofa, work space with writing desk, a mini fridge and microwave, and plush bedding as well as spacious suites with separate living and sleeping spaces, fully equipped kitchens, whirlpool tubs, and a dining area that is ideal for traveling families or groups. Guests interested in exploring Long Island will appreciate our ideal location that offers easy access to popular attractions, landmarks, and communities such as Fire Island, Lake Ronkonkoma, and the Long Island Maritime Museum. This MacArthur Airport hotel in Long Island offers modern conveniences such as a heated indoor pool, a 24-hour business center, onsite fitness studio, an onsite restaurant and bar, and over 6,000 sq. ft. of flexible event space to host business or social occasions.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Room was clean, quiet, and easily darkened for sleeping in. The bed was comfortable, staff friendly and helpful. The pool, hot tub, and surrounding area were clean and well maintained.
7.0 Good
Pros: Right off the expressway. Nice pool, great hot/tub spa.
Cons: Staff needs to replace coffee used in the AM. Food in the restaraunt was overpriced.
7.1 Good
Cons: very dissatisfied with having to pay for parking. we have used this hotel quite a few times previously and never had to pay to park in a lot that was half full. i just don't get it, except that it is an easy way to increase the cost. I question whether I return simply on principle of not being advised when I made reservation that the parking policy had changed.
5.0 Okay
Pros: Room was disappointing. Bathroom was in poor shape. There was no vanity no counter space in the bathroom. No tub. It was just like a public bathroom. The pool area was filthy. The tiles in the pool area was extremely filthy and the towels were just disgusting. Old rags it was.
7.5 Good
Pros: Time I spent with my girlfriend, it was more like down time for us both.
Cons: N/A
7.5 Good
Pros: The staff saved this place. They were extremely friendly!
Cons: The property itself is pretty old and the rooms are dated & worn
4.6 Okay
Pros: Staff sweet at check in
Cons: Bathroom outdated and mold between tile and bathtub , carpets dirty, elevators dirty and flowers on floor
7.5 Good
Pros: Staff was very friendly
Cons: Older hotel that could use some TLC
7.1 Good
Cons: Decided to charge $10 per day for parking, After already checked in, and also with the booking clearly saying Free parking, couldn't be bothered arguing with the Front desk lady, and emailing the GM, easier not to go back.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: The room size
Cons: The shower
5.8 Okay
Pros: not good but liked the lounge area and outdoor
Cons: blow dryer did not work or coffee maker no remote and asked for 1 never received pool was not warm (indoor pool) only 1 person at starbucks took over 40 mins (no lie) for coffee and oatmeal
7.5 Good
Pros: N/A
Cons: We had a room on the backside of the hotel. Looked out at walls and parking lot. Lighting in room could have been better. Reception on the LG tv was terrible; screen too small.
The Pridwin Hotel - Shelter Island Heights - Building
11
8.1 Excellent (215 reviews)
C$ 306+
Overview Reviews
Located in Shelter Island Heights, The Pridwin Hotel is near the bay, within a 5-minute walk of Crescent Beach and Shelter Island Tennis Club. Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby, multilingual staff, and luggage storage. A ferry terminal shuttle is provided at no charge, and free self parking is available onsite.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Location
Cons: Walking to room from parking lot
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The water view room was gorgeous
Cons: Nothing. We loved everything
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Great location, great vibe. Low key, quiet and comfortable.
Cons: Rooms were tiny.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Across the street from the beach. Amazing breakfast included. Super clean. Nice staff.
Cons: Nothing
10.0 Excellent
Pros: staff location sevice it was all good
Cons: nothing
4.6 Okay
Pros: Food excellent
Cons: Everything except location
5.8 Okay
Pros: The property, the free wine tasting, the bikes, the pool
Cons: The staff - it seemed to be run by a group of 16-18 year olds who were poorly trained and unsupervised. During the breakfast time, they stood as a flank, overstaffed, looking somber and bored, some looking at their phones. They never came by unsolicited, refilled coffee, asked how my meal was. The experience kicked my "mom" instinct into gear, and I was flustered as to what was going on with these youth and if anyone was teaching them what it means to do good work and how to be personable! Also, the property was clearly aging, and little repairs in the room were clearly done in a shoddy way (cracks in foundation repaired, but not pained over, for example). The 24inch television was insultingly small.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: The location is bucolic, such a welcome relief from the hype and traffic of the Hamptons. It's harder to get to and that's a useful deterrent. Pridwin is right on the water, outside dining has views of the Bay (called Peconic River) and dinner was lovely: delicious and well-executed. It is possible to walk or bike ride around the Island and thus simple exercise is steps away. Pridwin's own beach is narrow and not inviting. But steps down the way is a much wider, less rocky beach where sun bathing and swimming are available to all.
Cons: Breakfast left much to be desired, it was worse than camp food. Hard, rubbery eggs, brown water for coffee, the usual sugary cold cereals and toast; the only plus was delicious ripe fruit and plain yogurt. But it's included so i guess hard to complain? Check-out time was a tad early - 11:00 am given that check-in time is 4:00 pm and one is on vacation, 11:00 am is harsh. Nonetheless we had a relaxing, easy time here and would return.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Everything was great the staff was accommodating and The food was excellent
Cons: We had a problem adjusting the temperature of The water for a shower
2.9 Mediocre
Pros: The hotel never cleaned my room all day and then when I told management about the issue the next day they said they tried to and we told them to come back which is a clear lie. Poor customer service.
Cons: Poor customer service and hotel needs remodeling
Townsend Manor Inn - Greenport - Building
12
7.9 Good (178 reviews)
C$ 237+
Overview Reviews
Featuring an on-site marina and an outdoor pool, this Long Island inn is just a short drive from the beach. Greenport Village is 10 minutes’ walk from the property. A flat-screen satellite TV, microwave, and refrigerator are included in each guest room at the Townsend Manor Inn. The rooms have an en suite bathroom and a coffee machine. Guests can enjoy a game of shuffleboard or settle into a lounge chair by the Olympic-sized pool. The Greenport Townsend Manor Inn offers boat-docking at the marina. The cocktail lounge has full bar service, while the snack bar offers poolside service. The seasonal restaurant is open for breakfast and light fare. Island's End Golf & Country Club is 1 miles away. The ferry to Shelter Island is 15 minutes’ walk.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everything was better than expected. The room was clean and comfortable. And the location was perfect because it was walkable to downtown Greenport, so you didn't have to drive around too much. I also liked that it had a pool. In addition, it was very quiet and peaceful, with very few kids or noise. We will definitely be back again.
Cons: The refrigerator in our room wasn't operating ideally. Also one of the windows in our room was missing a screen, so we couldn't open it without bugs flying in. The parking lot at times was full. But none of these issues were that troublesome and could be easily cured.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Easy to park, well located to town, has a pool, a nice hotel.
Cons: Its price. For that price, there should be other amenities. The room is worth $'---- plus.
6.0 Good
Pros: The location was great, just a short walk to town. Too bad these innkeepers have everything old and brown, all they need to do is change brown bathcurtain, brown window treatment and brown furniture and make everything beige to show better.
Cons: The outside suggested a nice interior, when inside it was very dark and old and we felt like we made a mistake staying there. When going upstairs to our room it stunk like cigarettes or fireplace chemicals, the AC leaked. Brown everything. Ugly but clean
6.3 Good
Pros: Pool Parking
Cons: On a holiday weekend, breakfast was not even offered until the weekend. The bar closed early. For the amount of money we paid, it should be be an option. It should be INCLUDED. One building is nice and updated, but the others are outdated and musty.
4.6 Okay
Pros: Close to town
Cons: The room is dirty! Toaster oven grease all over! The freezer was disgusting! The bedding all needs to be thrown away The front desk lady needs to get a new job she is angry and miserable So uninviting
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Amazing stay close to downtown very clean
Cons: Nothing not to like
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Great pool, great location, comfortable accommodations.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: They had made coffees for one man and gave me one, too! Very homey. I have a suggestion that they have coffee and tea table/counter each morning!
Cons: Alarm clock went off at six a.m. - I had not set it and was deep into an enjoyable, comfortable night's sleep! I love these little radios and I guess I should've checked to make sure someone else hadn't set it previously.
6.3 Good
Pros: Location is ideal, a short walk into the main downtown. Great swimming pool. Historic charm.
Cons: Front desk staff was gruff. Our room had garbage from the previous guests. Stinky air fresheners in the room.
7.9 Good
Pros: Rooms were clean, very close walking distance to downtown greenport.
Cons: Food was OK, the a/c in the room was loud
6.3 Good
Pros: The Positives were the location and they allowed a 1 night booking where most other places required a two night minimum. The staff was very freindly
Cons: The Inn needs major restoration/repairs. The exterior needs painting and siding work, the porches/decks were in need of repair the Pool was dirty.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: nice setting, scenic view
Cons: nothing
White Blossom House Inn - Southold - Building
13
7.8 Good (30 reviews)
C$ 279+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at White Blossom House Inn in Southold, you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Mattebella Vineyards and Corey Creek Winery. Featured amenities include luggage storage and laundry facilities. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Mark and Mona are terrific hosts! My daughter and I had a wonderful time visiting my old home town!
Cons: Everything was great- we only wish our stay was longer!
6.3 Good
Pros: The building is really nice, wonderful garden (also the one just for us). The host was extremely nice in helping us with the laundry as the unit 4 did not have a washing machine
Cons: Really too expensive. We were expecting an historic and awesome accommodation, but the linoleum floors, the beds with wheels (moving then), the polyester curtain made it old not historic, at least inside - we were in apt 4. The kitchen could not accommodate 4
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Location and aprt size
9.6 Excellent
Pros: A very sweet place to stay at as a couple or a family. Very personable service from Mona and Mark. All extra amenities advertised were there for us to use.
7.5 Good
Pros: Very nice location close to the beach, we enjoyed the garden under the sun, our guests were lovely our hosts, inidacting the interesting activities to do in the region, the nice restaurants to go, the beaches to see, the ferry to take to discover the other part of the hamptons..very good experience !
10.0 Excellent
Pros: A delightful and charming old style cottage with all the facilities needed to eat in or explore the local area. Very comfortable and plenty of space. Outside seating and BBQ overlooking beautiful gardens an added benefit. Great location. Received a warm welcome and helpful introduction to the cottage and the local area.
Cons: Nothing - a great choice.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Cozy settings, friendly host, comfortable rooms.
7.1 Good
Pros: The location and host
Cons: Bed was not comfortable, some parts of the house had a very strong smell to animal urine.
4.2 Okay
Pros: Ok Location is everything! You are absolutly near to ab beach but that´s also a little problem. Everyone has to go by that house and when you are located next to the road that´s a major problem!
Cons: Historic and when they say historic they mean historic!!! Everything in this building is historic! The aircondition is window air conditioning and it´s at least 20 years old! Guess what it smells that way when you switch it on. When you try to switch to the shower the water tap underneath still spills out some water. All around in every single cafe, restaurant and even a shopping center had better access to the internet which is a pain in the a.. when you are trying to plan your next daytrip! Hey whe are in the 21st century and my 56k modem had a better put trough than this vericon thing. Which brings me to the next point. Everywhere and I mean everywhere was written out that you have HBO on your TV set but guess what, as I was asking for HBO the owner did not even appreciate me any looks and told me: "There´s no HBO!" This is the last problem at this home! The owner didn´t show up when we arrived and didn´t show up when we left. The only physical appearance was when we took a closer look at her pool as she had to tell us that we are not allowed to access it! I think they are having a motto their: "Don´t make any troubles at all and just leave your money without making any sensation!" it´s like they are squeezing every penny out of that building until it colappses!
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Well located, Mark and Mona are very friendly but provided complete privacy.
Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport - Ronkonkoma - Building
14
7.2 Good (499 reviews)
C$ 128+
Overview Reviews
When all you need is a solid deal on a simple stay, the Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport hotel in Ronkonkoma, NY is just what you are looking for. We're near attractions like Shea Stadium, Stony Brook University New York, Stony Brook University Medical Center, Smith Haven Mall and more. Enjoy amenities like free breakfast, free WiFi, an exercise room, a business center and an exercise room. Rooms include a TV, microwave, refrigerator, hair dryer, coffee maker, iron and ironing board. Also, earn rewards including free nights and gift cards with our Choice Privileges Rewards program. Must have 1 Adult 25 years or older in each room.
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Hotel was located within a few minutes drive from the airport, restaurants and stores (including Wal-Mart). The bed was comfortable. Breakfast buffet offered was excellent with good selection. Front desk staff was very friendly and caring and welcoming.
Cons: Room was small and road noise could be heard from within the room. The rooms were not luxury rooms but our room was clean and comfortable.
2.9 Mediocre
Pros: Worst experience . Bed horrible , bathroom horrible , noisey , ac/heater loud inefective. Broken window frame Overall the worse
Cons: Everything
6.7 Good
Pros: Only had toast and coffee. The coffee was very good.
Cons: The room could have been cleaner, there was a big gap between the door and the door frame, there was no finishing around the door.
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Staff are really nice! they will solve all of your problems. I was realy happy that they allow to change my room with a NON smoking room.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: The staff is friendly and accommodating
6.3 Good
Pros: They were polite about it
Cons: Put in a smoking room. Could not change rooms
2.5 Mediocre
Pros: Not much
Cons: In general it was clean. But it just wasn’t welcoming or where I would want
4.6 Okay
Pros: staff
Cons: need more cleaning
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Perfect location for us as we had 2 family functions to attend and the hotel was in the middle of both locations. Rooms were clean, housecleaning staff was very accommodating to our needs. Sid at the front desk greeted us in the morning with a smile and friendly manner.
6.0 Good
Pros: The breakfast was ok.
Cons: Yes. I requested for a non-smoking room. The moment we got inside the room, you can smell that it is a smoking room.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: It was the perfect size room for one person! I thought it would be noisy but with the a/c on, I heard very little street and inn noise.
7.5 Good
Pros: What eggs?? Continental breakfast not much protein. Bed was comfortable and clean.
Cons: TV bad reception at times. Was some kind of interference.
Overview Reviews
Get together at the Clarion Hotel and Conference Center in Ronkonkoma, NY. We are located less than a mile from the Long Island MacArthur Airport and offer free airport transportation. Enjoy additional amenities like our free WiFi, free weekday newspapers, a business center and fitness center. All guestrooms feature coffee makers, irons and ironing boards and flat-screen TVs. Select rooms also include refrigerators and microwaves. Also, earn rewards including free nights and gift cards with our Choice Privileges Rewards program.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: The room was huge, bed was comfy, plenty of pillows. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The facility was clean and the shower worked great. Awesome water pressure. Very close to the LIRR Ronkonkoma station.
Cons: Had a plumbing issue but it was fixed Very quickly.
2.0 Mediocre
Pros: Awful hotel. Filthy
Cons: Everything
6.0 Good
Pros: The room was clean but the phone did not work clearly,and to get into the the door, the card had to be swiped several times. Was given a wrong room first n had to go back and forth to the office in the heat overall experience was ok
Cons: Yes the fact that I was given a room that people were in and had to go back up to the office even though the girl apologized it was embarrassing and my son got upset I really thought I should of gotten a discount 30th to 31 so I was very disappointed
5.4 Okay
Cons: We got charged for smoking in the room when we didn't. We had complained that night that the people in the room next door were smoking and we got blamed for it. I am allergic to cigarette smoke so there is no way this would have occured.
5.4 Okay
Pros: I was able to book what I figured would be a decent place super last minute.
Cons: The room was not clean. The bathroom and linens did not look clean. This is not what I expected at all.
5.0 Okay
Pros: The hotel had amenities we wanted. Pool, fitness center, etc. Room was clean. Cleaning staff was wonderful - friendly, helpful, outstanding!
Cons: Patch of carpet in the hallway that was cut and patched in - but it was coming up, so it was very easy to trip on-several times. Carpet in hall smelled strange - musty. We were in traffic three hours. Got to hotel at 1:00. Signs everywhere that said "No early check in - Check in at 3:00 only". Why? I could see if we arrived at 10 a.m., but we had to wait almost two hours. Ridiculous. Front desk staff was distant. Not friendly or welcoming. We were not impressed.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The hotel employee at the front desk is wonderful. I stay there often and she is always nice. She is the best part of the hotel.
Cons: No
10.0 Excellent
Pros: location
6.3 Good
Pros: Bed was comfortable.
Cons: Out Dated and dark.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Comfortable
Cons: Nothing, everything was fine.
7.5 Good
Pros: It was clean.
Cons: The walls are so thin the couple next to us woke us up at 3am listening to them screaming and slamming the headboard at our heads! Very upset paying 183.00 for not even a 24 hr stay and no rest!
4.2 Okay
Pros: Close to airport. Bed was clean and comfortable.
Cons: Needs major renovation. Windows looking out onto property were filthy. When we arrived, had to walk through a group of men smoking at front door. Carpet in halls looked like it hadn’t been vacuumed in days. Bathroom wasn’t clean. Bottom of curtains were stuffed up into windowsill and very stained and dirty. Breakfast was not appealing.