Sister Bay hotels

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in Sister Bay

Sister Bay, WI, United States
Check-in
Check-out
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Good to know

Low season

April Cheapest month to stay with an average 35% drop in price.

High season

October Most expensive month to stay with an average 41% rise in price.

Average price (weeknight)

C$ 177 Average Sun. - Thu. price over the last 2 weeks.

Average price (weekend night)

C$ 246 Average Fri. & Sat. price over the last 2 weeks.

Top tips for finding the perfect Sister Bay hotel

FAQs when booking a hotel in Sister Bay

Are hotels in Sister Bay safe during the coronavirus (COVID-19) crisis?
How can I find hotels near me?

Where to stay in Sister Bay?

Our Heatmaps tool will help you find the perfect place to stay in Sister Bay by showing you how close hotel options are to major activities

Most recommended Sister Bay hotels

Show all
Scandinavian Lodge - Sister Bay - Building
1
9.4 Excellent (125 reviews)
C$ 127+
Overview Reviews
When you stay at Scandinavian Lodge in Sister Bay, you'll be near the beach, within a 15-minute walk of Waterfront Park and Lake Michigan. Featured amenities include a business center and laundry facilities.
9.4 Excellent
Pros: We had 6 total with college aged kids and wanted a villa where we could all stay. The 2 bedroom villa was perfect. Great value
Country House Resort - Sister Bay - Building
2
9.4 Excellent (303 reviews)
C$ 154+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Country House Resort in Sister Bay, you'll be on the waterfront, just a 3-minute walk from Lake Michigan and 7 minutes by foot from Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf. Featured amenities include a business center, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and a library.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Very nice getaway. Beautiful location right on Sister Bay. The staff friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. The room was comfortable and very roomy. Love the balcony right on the Bay.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Great breakfast and friendly staff
Cons: barking dogs in neighboring room was unpleasant
10.0 Excellent
Pros: loved the view of Sister Bay & the comfort of the room in general.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Breakfast was good but exactly the same every day. That was boring.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Location cleanliness comfortable
Cons: Breakfast and carpet smell of dog pee
Open Hearth Lodge - Sister Bay - Outdoors view
3
9.3 Excellent (406 reviews)
C$ 128+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Open Hearth Lodge in Sister Bay, you'll be near the beach, just a 2-minute walk from Bay Ridge Golf Course and 8 minutes by foot from Frykman Studio Gallery. Featured amenities include a computer station, laundry facilities, and an elevator. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everyone was friendly clean hotel price point
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Nice clean room, hot tub and pool, and the owners were very nice.
Cons: Breakfast selection was a little limited.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: we felt like they had anything we would have needed to make our stay feel like we were at home.
10.0 Excellent
Cons: The cable/satellite system didn’t have Fox Sports Wisconsin, so we couldn’t watch the Brewers game.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Value and all the amenities.
Cons: No.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: I was impressed by the staff, cleanliness, workout facility & breakfast. The only item I marked "good" rather than "excellent" was the room, which was a little outdated; HOWEVER, it was clean and comfortable, so what else do you really need?? I was super impressed by the gym. So many places advertise a gym, but only offer a treadmill and an Orbitrex or bike. The Open Hearth has an awesome treadmill, plus 3 other machines, a full weight bench AND plenty of floor space & mats for Yoga or Pilates. There's also a sauna in the basement gym, and a small pool and whirlpool on the first floor. The lobby is cozy, the breakfast room is bright and comfy, and the breakfast itself was more than the "light" breakfast the woman who checked us in said we'd find. I was expecting just a bagel and coffee; so, I was delightfully surprised to find 2 choices of cereal, plus oatmeal; hardboiled eggs; a pancake machine; fresh donuts; English muffins or whole wheat toast with peanut butter or jams; a bowl of apples (probably alternated with bananas or oranges); yogurt; and plenty of coffee! Additionally, if you don't feel like going out for lunch or dinner, you can purchase a frozen pizza and beer or local ciders at the front desk! The desk attendant will bake the pizza for you and deliver it to your room. This is a great place to relax. Plus, the location is super covenient. There are great restaurants and charming shops just up the road in Sister Bay, a Piggly Wiggly market closer still, and lots of hiking or X-C ski trails at the nearby Peninsula State Park. Thank you Open Hearth!
Coachlite Inn - Sister Bay - Building
4
8.7 Excellent (297 reviews)
C$ 121+
Overview Reviews
When you a stay at Coachlite Inn in Sister Bay, you'll be in a shopping district, within a 5-minute walk of Frykman Studio Gallery and Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf. Featured amenities include a 24-hour front desk and coffee/tea in a common area. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: I stayed in winter, so there was no breakfast. There is a dining area in the lobby, so I'm guessing they serve breakfast in summer. These are lovely rooms in a large motel-type complex just off Hwy 42 either in or very near Ephraim. The rooms are lovely, great beds, fairly simple, but do have fridge, microwave, hair dryer, ironing board & iron. Some rooms have "Bay" view.
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Close to town.
Cons: It was a little outdated.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Furnish of room and Cleaning are perfect. We had great one day at Coachlite Inn.
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Small microwave and small fridge in room. I liked that they had a fresh roll of paper towels on the counter. against the wall was a TV table if you wanted to use it in another section or next to the bed. A round table and two nice chairs. The room was small but it was enough for her me on my own or even if I had a friend with me.
Cons: I had trouble trying to get the water turned on for a shower it seemed liked the handle would slip and not catch. It definitely needed to be repaired.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: It's a nice place to stay.
Cons: The stairs to the second floor and the broken window that I wasn't able to close on a cold windy night.
The Inn at Little Sister Hill - Sister Bay - Bedroom
5
9.1 Excellent (137 reviews)
C$ 125+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at The Inn at Little Sister Hill in Sister Bay, you'll be in a state park, just a 2-minute walk from Bay Ridge Golf Course and 6 minutes by foot from Lake Michigan. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Free self parking is available onsite.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Family friendly. Playground make a big difference. Friendly staff. Good location. Nice property and setting
Cons: no complaints
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Location, Layout of the Hotel Rooms (Kids loved it) and Fully Functional Kitchen
Cons: Nothing Specific
Eagle Harbor Inn - Ephraim - Building
6
9.4 Excellent (342 reviews)
C$ 165+
Overview Reviews
When you a stay at Eagle Harbor Inn in Ephraim, you'll be near the beach, just steps from Lake Michigan and Eagle Harbor. The front desk is staffed during limited hours.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Location staff.
Cons: Nothing
7.0 Good
Pros: The charm... Hot tub was awesome!!! Bed was comfy
Cons: We did some cooking and burners on stove we're wonky. Not enough silverware. Thought the TV was to small in odd spot. Need upgrade
10.0 Excellent
Pros: breakfast was not included
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Breakfast was great! Staff were very helpful.
Cons: Very small room first night. Inadequate closet space.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Last minute decision. Were able to just book one night on a holiday. Check in process was well laid out. Room was wonderful. They had a deck of cards when we needed it. She remembered my name at check out. We have stayed there before and always come back because of the wonderful vibe the place has.
Waterbury Inn - Ephraim - Building
7
8.9 Excellent (201 reviews)
C$ 153+
Overview Reviews
Located in Ephraim, Waterbury Inn is within a 15-minute walk of Lake Michigan and Eagle Harbor. Featured amenities include a business center and laundry facilities. Free self parking is available onsite.
5.1 Okay
Cons: When returning to the room we had a piece of paper letting us know that there would be no water the next day and we should boil any water. They provided a jug of drinking water. Furthermore, we needed to let a maintenance person into the room at 8am.
Edgewater Resort - Ephraim - Building
8
9.1 Excellent (352 reviews)
C$ 153+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Edgewater Resort in Ephraim, you'll be on the beach, just steps from Eagle Harbor and a 2-minute drive from Peninsula State Park. The front desk is staffed during limited hours.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The room was immaculate and sunny and inviting! The views of the water were sensational!
9.0 Excellent
Pros: This is right across from the water and has a private beach area. you can easily walk into town and restaurants. The room was comfortable and well laid out.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The porch and view.
Cons: The side with gs of building limited the view a.little bit so the whole bay could not be seen.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: clean room 2 fireplaces, beautiful view of lake
Cons: nothing
9.0 Excellent
Pros: I love this resort and appreciated all the cleanliness efforts due to Covid 19. I was a bit disappointed in the loud construction happening on the building while I was staying there.
Cons: See construction comment above.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The hot tub
Cons: Wish we would have went in the summer
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Off season it is quiet and boasts a room view of the beautiful bay and sunsets.
Cons: No
10.0 Excellent
Pros: We like the lake view and that we got our own private deck.
Cons: Bring your own pillows, your head will sink to the floor.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: the breakfast was amazing!!! I can't wait to go back and the staff was very helpful with anything I needed. if I needed something I would call or go to the desk and they would get the things I asked for. thank you
Cons: there is not one thing I didn't like about where I stayed everything so clean and fresh when I walked into the room
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Room was spectacular. Location was exactly what we wanted.Staff was mostly helpful.
Cons: The area experienced a power outage in the early morning while we were showering and trying to pack up.No windows in dark bathroom. Staff should've contacted guests to provide some kind of battery lighting to assist the guests.
Ephraim Motel - Ephraim - Outdoors view
9
9.0 Excellent (341 reviews)
C$ 125+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Ephraim Motel in Ephraim, you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Bay Ridge Golf Course and Frykman Studio Gallery. Featured amenities include a business center and luggage storage. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everything was great
6.3 Good
Pros: Location
Cons: Bed - linens - pillows - towels
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Quiet, clean and very friendly staff. Would definitely stay here again.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: staff went out of their way to make our stay more comfortable. My husband did not like the firmness of the mattress, and they padded up his side of the bed with blankets. This made it much more comfortable to him.
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Very nice room and decor; lovely living room for breakfast; quiet setting with trees, nice breakfast and host.
Cons: The AC/heating unit blew right on the bed and the low fan setting wasn't really low.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The staff and the location close to lots of places
Cons: Rooms were a little small
Somerset Inn & Suites - Ephraim - Bedroom
10
8.9 Excellent (184 reviews)
C$ 135+
Overview Reviews
Located in Ephraim, Somerset Inn & Suites is a 2-minute drive from Eagle Harbor and 6 minutes from Peninsula State Park. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Great spot...loved it! Clean rooms, very hot hot tub, cool staff, central to all of DC- nice place to stay!
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Consider pastries in office in the mornings. Have at least one room that is fully suitable for handicapped people. Morning newspapers in the lobby.
Cons: Even after turning off the electric heat our room was very warm. Turning on the air conditioner didn't help much because we think it needed freon.
6.0 Good
Pros: the location,, and the pool,, it was a warm day. Also, forgot my I pad in the room, and they were more than helpful at returning it to me, and well wrapped,, the I pad work fine. A little nerve racking, when we realized it was not with us. Nice people.
Cons: relieved that it was not the other hotel I had stayed at in FEB. Very nice.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: The hotel is meticulously maintained. We were impressed with the cleanliness of the hotel and friendliness of the staff.
Cons: N/A
8.8 Excellent
Pros: I loved how friendly and accommodating the staff was! We were travelling with a service dog and the staff offered to upgrade our room for free so we could be near an exit. The room was beautiful with a fireplace!! From the moment we walked in the door, we felt welcome including Sadie (service dog). Great environment!
Cons: The pullout bed was very uncomfortable. The rooms smell like bugspray which I'm sure can't be helped since most of the hotels in Door County are in a wooded setting.
7.0 Good
Pros: It was comfortable and reasonably priced. I would recommend it, but on a non-humid day. It is an older facility, as are most places in Door County, and in the room, they did spruce it up with updated curtains, bedding, paintings. It was adequate and ok for the price. The patio off the room was a nice touch. It was nice to use as a base, but not a room I'd want to spend time in other than sleeping. It was nice to have a refrigerator, microwave and hair dryer.
Cons: It was so very humid in the room. The carpet and the sheets felt wet all night. I would've thought on such a humid day that they would have turned on the air conditioning ahead of time. While it cooled down fairly quickly, the humidity never left the room and was uncomfortable. The patio door was open (first floor) when I first arrived and gave me an uneasy feeling when I walked in. I intended to read before going to bed, but the lights were way too dim.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: It was really, really clean. We enjoyed it that it was as suite. We were there 4 nights and the extra space is nice.
Cons: Next time we would ask for a main floor room the stars were long.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Fireplace and Jacuzzi were so nice for the cold days!
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Suite was very clean, easy back door access to our car, fireplace was great! Also liked the fact that it wasnt a 3 night minimum the weekend we stayed.
3.3 Mediocre
Cons: The beds were uncomfortable...need to have a memory foam added to them. No Breakfast...for the cost of the room it should have been some kind of breakfast food available. The bathroom, the stool and shower were to small-could not even close the door to use the stool unless you got behind the door and closed. I would say it needs an update.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The location was beautiful and the rooms were neat and clean with decor that matched the surrounding Door County vibe! Would stay there again in a heartbeat!
4.5 Okay
Cons: Old,dated, worn out, needs a coat of paint on outside ,inside needs updating!
High Point Inn - Ephraim - Pool
11
9.2 Excellent (115 reviews)
C$ 200+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at High Point Inn in Ephraim, you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Bay Ridge Golf Course and Frykman Studio Gallery.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: The accommodations are always very clean. Additionally, during our last stay, I left a necklace behind. After I called to ask about it, the staff kept looking for it until they found it for me & called with updates without acting like it was an inconvenience or bother. I appreciated the way they handled it a great deal!!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Beautiful facility! Centrally located. This was our second visit and we will be back!!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Room was exceptionally clean!! Beds were comfortable, rooms were quiet, and the kitchen was easy to use. Enjoyed the pool, arcade, and playground. Coffee and tea in the lobby in the morning is hot and convenient!
Cons: The fitness center didn’t open until 8 which for us was too late to use.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Very nice hotel, rooms were excellent, very comfortable. Beds were very comfortable. LOVE that they have plenty of pillows (I need my extra pillows). Internet connected very easily and had great bandwidth. Location was very good, not far from Sister Bay and close to Ephraim and Fish Creek. Would certainly stay here again.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Pretty building. Rooms cozy and comfy. Liked the kitchen in suite. Hottub in bigger bedroom was relaxing!
Cons: Too much snow in parking lot and large ice spots. Lot was hard to maneuver around.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The rooms are really spacious. The kitchen was well stocked with dishes. I have stayed here many times and will be back again.
Cons: Pool was cold.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Booked this without any worries for others. Awesome stay
Village Green Lodge - Ephraim - Building
12
9.4 Excellent (136 reviews)
C$ 212+
Overview
Located in Ephraim, Village Green Lodge is on the Strip, just a 5-minute walk from Eagle Harbor and a 3-minute drive from Peninsula State Park. Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby and a library. Free self parking is available onsite.
Hillside Inn of Ephraim - Ephraim - Building
13
8.9 Excellent (21 reviews)
C$ 504+
Overview
A stay at Hillside Inn of Ephraim places you in the heart of Ephraim, steps from Lake Michigan and Eagle Harbor. Featured amenities include a 24-hour business center, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and luggage storage. Free self parking is available onsite.

Best rooms in Sister Bay

Country House Resort - Sister Bay - Building
1
9.4 Excellent (303 reviews)
C$ 154+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Country House Resort in Sister Bay, you'll be on the waterfront, just a 3-minute walk from Lake Michigan and 7 minutes by foot from Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf. Featured amenities include a business center, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and a library.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Very nice getaway. Beautiful location right on Sister Bay. The staff friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. The room was comfortable and very roomy. Love the balcony right on the Bay.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Great breakfast and friendly staff
Cons: barking dogs in neighboring room was unpleasant
10.0 Excellent
Pros: loved the view of Sister Bay & the comfort of the room in general.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Breakfast was good but exactly the same every day. That was boring.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Location cleanliness comfortable
Cons: Breakfast and carpet smell of dog pee
Open Hearth Lodge - Sister Bay - Outdoors view
2
9.3 Excellent (406 reviews)
C$ 128+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Open Hearth Lodge in Sister Bay, you'll be near the beach, just a 2-minute walk from Bay Ridge Golf Course and 8 minutes by foot from Frykman Studio Gallery. Featured amenities include a computer station, laundry facilities, and an elevator. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everyone was friendly clean hotel price point
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Nice clean room, hot tub and pool, and the owners were very nice.
Cons: Breakfast selection was a little limited.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: we felt like they had anything we would have needed to make our stay feel like we were at home.
10.0 Excellent
Cons: The cable/satellite system didn’t have Fox Sports Wisconsin, so we couldn’t watch the Brewers game.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Value and all the amenities.
Cons: No.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: I was impressed by the staff, cleanliness, workout facility & breakfast. The only item I marked "good" rather than "excellent" was the room, which was a little outdated; HOWEVER, it was clean and comfortable, so what else do you really need?? I was super impressed by the gym. So many places advertise a gym, but only offer a treadmill and an Orbitrex or bike. The Open Hearth has an awesome treadmill, plus 3 other machines, a full weight bench AND plenty of floor space & mats for Yoga or Pilates. There's also a sauna in the basement gym, and a small pool and whirlpool on the first floor. The lobby is cozy, the breakfast room is bright and comfy, and the breakfast itself was more than the "light" breakfast the woman who checked us in said we'd find. I was expecting just a bagel and coffee; so, I was delightfully surprised to find 2 choices of cereal, plus oatmeal; hardboiled eggs; a pancake machine; fresh donuts; English muffins or whole wheat toast with peanut butter or jams; a bowl of apples (probably alternated with bananas or oranges); yogurt; and plenty of coffee! Additionally, if you don't feel like going out for lunch or dinner, you can purchase a frozen pizza and beer or local ciders at the front desk! The desk attendant will bake the pizza for you and deliver it to your room. This is a great place to relax. Plus, the location is super covenient. There are great restaurants and charming shops just up the road in Sister Bay, a Piggly Wiggly market closer still, and lots of hiking or X-C ski trails at the nearby Peninsula State Park. Thank you Open Hearth!
The Inn at Little Sister Hill - Sister Bay - Bedroom
3
9.1 Excellent (137 reviews)
C$ 125+
Overview Reviews
With a stay at The Inn at Little Sister Hill in Sister Bay, you'll be in a state park, just a 2-minute walk from Bay Ridge Golf Course and 6 minutes by foot from Lake Michigan. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Free self parking is available onsite.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Family friendly. Playground make a big difference. Friendly staff. Good location. Nice property and setting
Cons: no complaints
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Location, Layout of the Hotel Rooms (Kids loved it) and Fully Functional Kitchen
Cons: Nothing Specific
Coachlite Inn - Sister Bay - Building
4
8.7 Excellent (297 reviews)
C$ 121+
Overview Reviews
When you a stay at Coachlite Inn in Sister Bay, you'll be in a shopping district, within a 5-minute walk of Frykman Studio Gallery and Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf. Featured amenities include a 24-hour front desk and coffee/tea in a common area. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: I stayed in winter, so there was no breakfast. There is a dining area in the lobby, so I'm guessing they serve breakfast in summer. These are lovely rooms in a large motel-type complex just off Hwy 42 either in or very near Ephraim. The rooms are lovely, great beds, fairly simple, but do have fridge, microwave, hair dryer, ironing board & iron. Some rooms have "Bay" view.
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Close to town.
Cons: It was a little outdated.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Furnish of room and Cleaning are perfect. We had great one day at Coachlite Inn.
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Small microwave and small fridge in room. I liked that they had a fresh roll of paper towels on the counter. against the wall was a TV table if you wanted to use it in another section or next to the bed. A round table and two nice chairs. The room was small but it was enough for her me on my own or even if I had a friend with me.
Cons: I had trouble trying to get the water turned on for a shower it seemed liked the handle would slip and not catch. It definitely needed to be repaired.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: It's a nice place to stay.
Cons: The stairs to the second floor and the broken window that I wasn't able to close on a cold windy night.