Amara Cay Resort

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
+1 305 664 0073

Cheapest
rate per night

8.7

Excellent
based on 1,504 reviews
Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada, FL, United States
Check-in
-
Check-out
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Provider Nightly total
TripAdvisor C$ 217
Hotels.com C$ 273
HotelTonight C$ 298
TripAdvisor
Hotels.com
HotelTonight

Good to know

Distance to city centre 3.9 km
Location rating 9.4
Nearest Airport Miami
Distance to airport 106.3 km

Rooms

Check-in
Check-out

Queen Rooms

C$ 405+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly base price
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 405 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 443 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 465 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 484 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 498 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 503 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 503 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 533 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 560 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 692 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 767 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 860 per night

Superior Rooms

C$ 217+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly base price
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 217 per night

Double Rooms

C$ 554+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly base price
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 554 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 565 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 713 per night

Deluxe Rooms

C$ 291+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly base price
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 291 per night

King Rooms

C$ 343+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly base price
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 343 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 380 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 388 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 431 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 447 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 459 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 531 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 547 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 553 per night

Standard Rooms

C$ 273+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly base price
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 273 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 301 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 309 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 311 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 315 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 320 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 322 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 337 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 338 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 339 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 345 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 347 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 378 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 378 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 378 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 384 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 398 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 407 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 429 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 450 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 461 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 517 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 533 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 550 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 554 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 567 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 580 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 606 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 638 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 655 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 664 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 666 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 684 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 694 per night

Reviews

Pros

Cons

Traveller rating

170
58
20
6
0

Time of year

Traveller type

Show reviews that mention

+
beautiful hotel in 12 reviews
bed was very comfortable in 10 reviews
friendly staff in 114 reviews
good food in 38 reviews
great view in 43 reviews
lighting in the bathroom in 25 reviews
location was great in 44 reviews
paddle boards in 20 reviews
pool area in 167 reviews
really enjoyed our stay in 3 reviews
restaurant service in 59 reviews
right on the beach in 59 reviews
room was nice in 20 reviews
sofa bed in 6 reviews
tiki bar in 71 reviews
towels at the pool in 103 reviews
view of the parking lot in 41 reviews
  • Excellent
    Aug. 2019
    10.0

    From the moment we stepped inside the property is stunning. We were given a complimentary room upgrade to an ocean view room. The pool was spectacular and we enjoyed using the free kayaks at the resort. The staff went above and beyond for us! We enjoyed lunch poolside and went to dinner down the street at lazy days after a recommendation from the bartender. We will definitely be back!

    There were some odd hours for the lobby restaurant. Not a major issue because you could also go to the pool bar.

  • Excellent
    Aug. 2019
    10.0

    The staff was very courteous. Always had fresh towels.

    Pillow was too soft.

  • Excellent
    Aug. 2019
    10.0

    Proximity to beach, tiki bar

  • Excellent
    Aug. 2019
    9.6

    The comfy decor and size of the room was awesome.

    Two things, Ugh the quality of toilet paper is that a trashy gas station. Second, we expected a USB since the resort has been recently upgraded.

  • Okay
    Jul. 2019
    5.8

    It has super loud rock music in a Tiki Bar in an island, which does not go with the vibe. The breakfast was ok, and few people im staff..

No reviews found. Try removing a filter, changing your search, or clear all to view reviews.

About

Overview

The Amara Cay Resort is a destination all its own, and sits right along the waterfront in beautiful Islamorada, Florida. This is part of the famous Florida Keys region and is half the way between Miami and Key West. Islamorada has long been known as the Fishing Capital of the World thanks to the calmness of its crystal clear waters, the surrounding coral reefs, and endless number of vendors and tour operators.

The location makes it perfect for individuals, couples or families and groups eager for a tropical getaway, and the amenities of the resort only enhance its value as a vacation destination. There is the fishing and the swimming in the surrounding waters, but there are also such niceties as free shuttle services, a private beach area, manicured gardens and grounds, pet-friendly policies, bike borrowing, a fitness center, swimming pool area, water sports, outdoor lounges, and Reelburger. The last is a fantastic burger restaurant on the premises and it stands near to the tiki bar where signature cocktails and tasty bites are always available.

The resort features guest rooms and more luxurious suites. All are furnished with premium bedding and linens, furnished balconies or terraces, work desks, entertainment systems with cable and movies, free Wi-Fi, hot beverage systems, large and private baths with signature toiletries, and more. The suites feature full kitchens with dining areas, and beach chairs and pool towels.

When seeking a one-stop location for a Florida Keys holiday, the Amara Cay Resort is sure to delight.

More

Features

Free parking
Free airport shuttle
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
Spa

8.7 Excellent

based on 1,504 reviews

9.4

Location

9.2

Pool

4.4

Breakfast

2.3

Wellness

Things to Know

  • Great view
  • Nice building
  • Stylish hotel
  • Pleasant hotel grounds

Check in

4:00 PM

Check out

11:00 AM

Cancellation/prepayment

Policies vary by room type and provider.

Amenities

Fitness centre
Disabled Access
Business centre
Concierge service
Cribs available
Gift shop
Laundry facilities
Meeting/Banquet facilities
Bicycle rental
Outdoor pool
No smoking
Restaurant
Bar/Lounge
Express check out
Cable or satellite TV
Air-conditioned
24hr front desk
Safe
Pets not allowed
Free parking
Playground
Private beach
Designated smoking area
Storage available
Wedding services
Terrace/Patio
Internet
Wi-Fi
EV charging station
Elevator
Massage
Hairdryer
ATM on-site

Photos

Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada - Building All Photos (20)
Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada - Banquet hall Banquets (1)
Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada - Bar Bar (1)
Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada - Bathroom Bathroom (1)
Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada - Bedroom Bedroom (2)

Location

Most Popular Landmarks

  • Bud n' Mary's Dive Center 336 m
  • Bud n' Mary's Fishing Marina 341 m
  • Hurricane Monument 2.7 km
  • Cheeca Lodge & Spa 2.8 km
  • History of Diving Museum 4.9 km
  • Theater of the Sea 7.3 km

Getting Around

Miami 106.3 km
Miami Seaplane Base 108.7 km
Miami 112.8 km
Hollywood 132.9 km

Nearby hotels

Closest

8.4 Excellent (354 reviews)
0.19 km
C$ 247+
8.1 Excellent (844 reviews)
0.59 km
C$ 394+
8.8 Excellent (761 reviews)
0.65 km
C$ 297+

Cheapest

8.4 Excellent (354 reviews)
0.19 km
C$ 247+
8.8 Excellent (761 reviews)
0.65 km
C$ 297+
8.1 Excellent (844 reviews)
0.59 km
C$ 394+

Most recommended

9.8 Excellent (91 reviews)
3.2 km
C$ 491+
8.8 Excellent (761 reviews)
0.65 km
C$ 297+
8.6 Excellent (1,264 reviews)
2.89 km
C$ 411+