Amara Cay Resort

Amara Cay Resort

8.7
Excellent

Based on 1,369 reviews
 
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
  +1 305 664 0073
Amara Cay Resort - Islamorada, FL, United States
Check-in
Check-out
Compare vs. KAYAK |
TripAdvisor C$ 216
Hotels.com C$ 272
HotelTonight C$ 297
TripAdvisor
per night
Hotels.com
per night
HotelTonight
per night

Rooms

Check-in
Check-out

Double Rooms

C$ 553+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly Base Price
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 553 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 564 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 712 per night

King Rooms

C$ 343+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly Base Price
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 343 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 379 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 387 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 431 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 447 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 458 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 531 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 547 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 553 per night

Superior Rooms

C$ 216+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly Base Price
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 216 per night

Standard Rooms

C$ 272+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly Base Price
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 272 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 300 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 309 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 310 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 315 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 320 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 322 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 337 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 338 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 339 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 345 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 347 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 377 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 377 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 377 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 383 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 398 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 407 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 428 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 449 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 461 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 517 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 532 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 549 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 553 per night
IMAGE
King bed
C$ 567 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 579 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 606 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 637 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 654 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 663 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 665 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 683 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 693 per night

Deluxe Rooms

C$ 291+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly Base Price
IMAGE
Unknown
C$ 291 per night

Queen Rooms

C$ 404+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly Base Price
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 404 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 442 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 464 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 484 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 497 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 502 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 502 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 532 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 560 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 691 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 766 per night
IMAGE
Queen bed
C$ 859 per night

Reviews

Traveller rating

118
42
14
6
0

Time of year

Traveller type

Show reviews that mention

+
tiki bar
beach area
pool area
paddle boards
bathroom lighting
towels at the pool
view of the parking lot
room was clean
beautiful hotel
kayaks snorkeling
various games
great staff
outdoor cafes
comfortable beds
hotel with a great
dead battery
  • Excellent
    Jul 2017
    8.8

    Beautiful lobby/restaurant beach area and pool. Staff amazing, friendly and helpful.

    rooms sparse. Need more lighting and seating but other than that clean and modern.

  • Excellent
    Feb 2017
    8.5

    Nice clean hotel with a great staff but

    The rooms are very nice but they are missing a microwave which is very much needed. They have a Keurig Coffee maker and a few K cups to get your day started, plus there is a mini fridge but there was no way to heat your coffee if you like to add milk and cream unless you go down to the front desk and ask them to heat it for you. One other plus was they did freeze our fish (caught from charter fishing) and held it until our departure. Just make sure to remember to pick it up upon your departure. :

  • Excellent
    Feb 2017
    9.4

    Would definitely return

    The staff were exceptional especially Steve, Snl and David.i was in love with the decor and the cleanliness of the facility. I would definitely go back. And the view from our room was amazing.

    The construction that was in progress near the pool area was alittle annoying . Also did not care for the breakfast experience the food was just okay and very pricey for what you get.

  • Excellent
    Sep 2016
    10.0

    Great stay for Memorial Weekend

    There was some remodeling but I'm sure once lt's done it would be amazing

  • Okay
    Aug 2016
    5.4

    the rooms were big, nice beds

    bathroom was dirty also the towels were dirty ( they had hair on them) The service at the restaurant was slow

  • Excellent
    May 2016
    10.0

    Hotel was beautifully decorated with a nice pool, beach and outdoor bar

    Nothing

  • Excellent
    Apr 2016
    9.1

    The resort was clean and well designed and appointed after the renovation.

    They had given my reservation away and took a while to assign a room while they looked for the snafu. They did provide free drinks and breakfast for the delay, though! So that was thoughtful and accommodated for the delay.

  • Excellent
    Apr 2016
    10.0

    very nice place to stay

    the beach is nice, not too many beaches in the keys. very nice view of the ocean, and it was great to be able to have access to swim in the ocean. the pool was very nice , as well, kids love the pool.The rooms and everything else were very comfortable.

    Because I am on a lower budget, the only way we were able to stay there was through a 3rd party offer. We were there only for 2 nights. Food and drinks are always pretty expensive at places like this, so I couldn't partake, as I would of liked.

  • Okay
    Apr 2016
    4.8

    The staff was exceptional - took care of the snake in my room, showed me how to use coffee pot, and telephone, fixed the TV and put new battery in safe. All unnecessary if it had been done prior to my arrival. The decor is lovely and the grounds pretty and well kept. Liked the hot tub. Kudoos to Annette

    I don't think the room was checked prior to my occupancy. or been occupied in some time The TV didn't work, the safe didn't work (dead battery) no instructions as to use of phone, coffee pot. the floor of balcony was dirty, no instructions to prevent shower flooding bathroom. I don;t expect to have to call maintenance several times in a 4 day stay when I go for rest and relaxation.It is a handicap room and a flooded floor could cause me to fall...

  • Good
    Apr 2016
    7.7

    New updates but unable to accommodate 4 people

    Renovations were very well done has a luxury feel to it. Beautiful views pool side. Great little bocce court and swings and slide. Good central location in the keys. Small hidden hot tub.

    We reserved for 4 people and the uncomfortable pull out couch with springs in the mattress was only a twin. We tried to get another room each of the 4 nights with no luck. Lots of tiny jelly fish (sea lice) in the ocean entry area. I did not get stung, but both of my kids did.

  • Excellent
    Mar 2016
    9.4

    Stay here

    I liked everything about it! The front desk member Annette was most helpful.

    I didn't bring my id to get drinks because I didn't want to lose it in the sand or water. I was denied a drink at the Amarca Bay bar outside. I recommend that there a be a system in place that allows guests to charge drinks to their room. Try temporary database of guest's proof of age to the Front desk conputers, or distribute a proof of age wristband.

  • Good
    Dec 2015
    6.8

    Ask questions first, and then ask again

    Great hot tub area, nice to have a bar right near the pool so you can have lunch pool side, little play area in the sand was a nice plus, very modern and the food was incredible.

    So many things...we asked for the nearest boat ramp and they directed us to one miles away when they had one on location. I called ahead and asked about accommodations. They said every room has a pull out couch. It was a pull out chair...not couch. Couldn't sleep our family comfortably. Wanted ice, 2 different staff directed me to 2 different floors where there wasn't an ice machine.

No reviews found. Try removing a filter, changing your search, or clear all to view reviews.

About

Overview

At Amara Cay Resort, we want our guests to be inspired to craft their own Islamorada adventure. Let our waterfront setting set the stage. We’re naturally laid-back and carefree but we take hospitality seriously. After all, this is the Sport Fishing Capital of the World. We’re here to help our guests achieve a state of bliss – whether it comes at the end of a day spent fighting a prized catch, lounging in a hammock along the shore or diving in a nearby reef.

Whatever you do, rest assured, you’ll be making memories to last a lifetime. From tropical cocktails at Sparrows Rum Bar to diving excursions, fishing charters and all manner of watersports, Amara Cay Resort is easy Islamorada tranquility redefined.

Amara Cay Resort

More

Features

Free Parking
Free Airport Shuttle
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet Friendly
Spa

8.7 Excellent

Based on 1,369 reviews

9.3

Location

9.2

Vibe

5.6

Breakfast

4.5

Value for money

Things to Know

  • Friendly atmosphere
  • Great view
  • Pleasant hotel grounds
  • Stylish hotel

Check in

4:00 PM

Check out

11:00 AM

Cancellation/prepayment

Policies vary by room type and provider.

Amenities

Fitness centre
Increased Accessibility
Business centre
Concierge service
Cribs available
Gift shop
Laundry facilities
Meeting/Banquet facilities
Bicycle rental
Outdoor pool
No smoking
Restaurant
Bar/Lounge
Express check out
Cable or satellite TV
Air-Conditioned
24 Hour Front Desk
Safe
Pets not allowed
Free parking
Playground
Private beach
Designated smoking area
Storage available
Wedding services
Terrace/Patio
Internet
Wi-Fi
Elevator
Massage
Hairdryer

Location

Most Popular Landmarks

  • Bud n' Mary's Dive Center 336 m
  • Hurricane Monument 2.7 km
  • History of Diving Museum 4.9 km
  • Theater of the Sea 7.3 km
  • Anne's Beach 10.3 km
  • Long Key State Park 19 km

Nearby hotels

Closest

8.2 Excellent (296 reviews)
0.19 km
C$ 208+
8.4 Excellent (1,082 reviews)
0.59 km
C$ 312+
8.8 Excellent (556 reviews)
0.65 km
C$ 249+

Cheapest

8.2 Excellent (296 reviews)
0.19 km
C$ 208+
8.8 Excellent (556 reviews)
0.65 km
C$ 249+
8.4 Excellent (1,082 reviews)
0.59 km
C$ 312+

Most recommended

8.8 Excellent (556 reviews)
0.65 km
C$ 249+
8.4 Excellent (1,082 reviews)
0.59 km
C$ 312+
8.2 Excellent (296 reviews)
0.19 km
C$ 208+