Sanibel Island car rentals

Search hundreds of rental car sites at once for car rental deals in Sanibel Island

Same drop-off
Wed 29/3
Wed 5/4
Driver's age:

Cheap car rentals in Sanibel Island

Passenger Van
Pick-up truck
Mini car in Sanibel Island
Economy car in Sanibel Island
Compact car in Sanibel Island
Intermediate car in Sanibel Island
Standard car in Sanibel Island
Full-size car in Sanibel Island
Luxury car in Sanibel Island
Minivan car in Sanibel Island
Passenger Van car in Sanibel Island
SUV car in Sanibel Island
Commercial car in Sanibel Island
Pick-up truck car in Sanibel Island

Car rental locations in Sanibel Island

Car rental directory

  • hertz

    Hertz car rental locations in Sanibel Island

    2 Locations

Good to know

Most popular car type


When to book a rental car in Sanibel Island

Average daily price per month
Rental car prices as pick-up date approaches

Top tips for renting a car in Sanibel Island

  • The law is clear in Sanibel Island about seatbelts. Everyone in the car, front or back seat, should wear a seatbelt at all times. You’ll find that all rental cars booked through KAYAK have well-functioning seatbelts. Children below five should be appropriately secured in a child restraint device. Those between four and five can be in a child seat or booster seat, depending on their height and weight. Moreover, those between six and twelve should remain in the back seat at all times and wear a seatbelt. You can rent an infant seat, child seat, or booster seat at the rental counter.
  • Just a heads up, before driving your car rental on Sanibel Island, you should know that traffic can be heavy, especially in the high season. Periwinkle Way is one of the major roads on Sanibel Island, and unfortunately, one of the busiest during rush hours. The morning rush is between 9:00 - 11:00 am, while the evening rush takes place between 4:00 - 6:00 pm. Avoid Periwinkle Way during these busy hours. Alternatively, you can bypass the traffic by taking the beach roads (West Gulf Drive to Casa Ybel Road to Middle Gulf Drive, then finally to Lindgren).
  • As part of the Sunshine State, it can get sweltering and humid on Sanibel Island. For that reason, you need to be mindful of the type of car you rent while visiting the region. A convertible is a great choice, especially if you’re on vacation. Driving with the top down, your favorite music on, and cool wind in your hair, there is hardly a better feeling. You can also opt for the less flashy cars with air conditioning to keep out the heat.
  • A visit to Sanibel Island isn’t complete without a trip to the beach for some fun in the sun. Whether you’re on Captiva or Sanibel Island, note that parking at the beach is limited and charged. You might need to arrive a bit earlier to get a great spot, and still, you’ll be charged about $5 an hour for the spot. Also, note that driving or parking on the beach isn’t allowed.
  • Book your rental car in Sanibel Island at least 1 day before your trip in order to get a below-average price
  • Compact rental cars in Sanibel Island are around 66% cheaper than other car types, on average

FAQs about renting a car in Sanibel Island