Find Cheap Flights from New York to Toronto Island

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Toronto Island

Depart
Return
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |

New York to Toronto Island Flight Information

Flights Arrive in Toronto Island
Flights Depart from New York
Flight Price C$ 230
Airlines Porter Airlines, Major Airline, Air Canada

Book cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island (round-trip)

Airports
Origin
New York
C$ 474
only
C$ 474
C$ 230
only
C$ 230
Syracuse
C$ 419
only
C$ 419
Buffalo
C$ 400
only
C$ 400
Destination
Toronto
C$ 230
only
C$ 230
Tue, 8 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 38m
Mon, 21 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 14 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.0

Pros: After taking a chance on an airline I had never heard of, we were pleasantly surprised! Although there was a weather related delay, they accommodated us on an earlier flight.

Cons: The plane was a bit loud

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Pros: Airport

Cons: Was late going to NewYork and coming home. We were able to get an early flight which was great. Island Aurpirt is wonderful. Price fantastic!

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Everything

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

Sat, 12 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
Sat, 26 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 250
Trip: 15 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Thu, 7 Mar
BUF
Buffalo
YTZ
Toronto Island
6h 32m
Tue, 12 Mar
YTZ
Toronto Island
BUF
Buffalo
5h 03m
C$ 400
Trip: 5 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Wed, 9 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 34m
Wed, 23 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 15 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

Pros: Cheaper than other airlines though the flight attendants are really great

Cons: Well you get what you pay Small plane, not as confortable seats

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Porter was great, bumped us up to an earlier flight because we had no checked baggage

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Pros: Airport

Cons: Was late going to NewYork and coming home. We were able to get an early flight which was great. Island Aurpirt is wonderful. Price fantastic!

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: The crew was friendly and welcoming

Cons: Our flight was delayed once again. Once we landed our carry on baggage was not given to us right away. We were told to wait for it outside the plane. After waiting, we were told we would have to pick it up at the baggage carousel with the checked luggage. We had to wait over 30 minutes for our carry on luggage.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

Tue, 29 Jan
LGA
New York LaGuardia
YTZ
Toronto Island
5h 00m
Sun, 3 Feb
YTZ
Toronto Island
LGA
New York LaGuardia
4h 01m
C$ 474
Trip: 6 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 23,328 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
YYC
YUL
Mediocre 2.0

Cons: I used Kayak to find my ticket and fill out my information (all kayak logos on top of the page and so on). However, when my confirmation email and e-ticket came in, they were issued by Budgetair.com. I had no experience with them and took it to be a reliable website since they were working with Kayak. However, I had to change/cancel my flight because of delayed passport delivery, and this is when everything turned very Ugly! I had to spend an hour over the phone to get connected to an agent with BudgetAir, who disconnected the line within 2 minutes saying: “please hold so I can pull up your information”. This game went on for 6 hours. I tried to connect with the airline directly to make the change, which was not possible since Budgetair had placed a restriction on this ticket. After 6-7 hours, which meant no work for me or lunch because I was sitting behind my desk with a phone on my hand, I got through an agent who was rude and impolite. He took 15 minutes to find flights for the new dates (I did it in 2 minutes on their website), and then told me to pay $315 in extra fess. When I inquired that the prices on your website for the exact same ticket is way cheaper than my original ticket price, he got angry and aggressive. Basically implying that I have no choice to take their offer as is, or let go of my original ticket price of over $2000. Long story short, DO NOT buy from BudgetAir if you like having a peace of mind!

MUC
YYZ
Excellent 8.6

Cons: Food at Air Canada. Very bad.

MEX
YYZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Pleasant Flight attendants and good pilot.

Cons: No free drinks at all! Cheap airline

YVR
YYZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Meals, comfort, polite staff

Cons: Nothing

YYZ
YVR
Good 6.6

Pros: The in flight attendants were very helpful and attentive. Boarding was quick and organized.

Cons: The entertainment system didn’t work well to start, and then stopped working altogether 2 hours into a 5hr flight. The staff tried to fix it and were very apologetic, which made up for it. The seats were a little too hard for me. I was pretty sore by the end of the trip.

Thu, 10 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 34m
Sat, 19 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 10 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

Pros: Cheaper than other airlines though the flight attendants are really great

Cons: Well you get what you pay Small plane, not as confortable seats

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: The crew was friendly and welcoming

Cons: Our flight was delayed once again. Once we landed our carry on baggage was not given to us right away. We were told to wait for it outside the plane. After waiting, we were told we would have to pick it up at the baggage carousel with the checked luggage. We had to wait over 30 minutes for our carry on luggage.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Was offered a earlier flight that was available when we arrived for check in

Cons: I thought I had paid for baggage in advance but obviously there was a glitch in the payment process so HATED the cost for 2 bags. We traveled with 6 other airlines within Europe and none charged this exorbitant amount... NOT VERY PLEASED Check in person wasn’t very pleasant to deal with. I think she was having a bad day!!! All other staff and flight attendants were pleasant and good to deal with.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

Mon, 31 Dec
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
Thu, 3 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 260
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, 11 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
Sun, 20 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 10 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: No issues. Everything took place on time. The staff were very accommodating and patient with the infants on board

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Porter was great, bumped us up to an earlier flight because we had no checked baggage

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.0

Pros: After taking a chance on an airline I had never heard of, we were pleasantly surprised! Although there was a weather related delay, they accommodated us on an earlier flight.

Cons: The plane was a bit loud

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: The crew was friendly and welcoming

Cons: Our flight was delayed once again. Once we landed our carry on baggage was not given to us right away. We were told to wait for it outside the plane. After waiting, we were told we would have to pick it up at the baggage carousel with the checked luggage. We had to wait over 30 minutes for our carry on luggage.

Sat, 12 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 40m
Sun, 20 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 9 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Porter was great, bumped us up to an earlier flight because we had no checked baggage

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Pros: Airport

Cons: Was late going to NewYork and coming home. We were able to get an early flight which was great. Island Aurpirt is wonderful. Price fantastic!

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: we finally got there

Cons: first time we flew porter air. flight was one hour late, then connecting porter flight was also late. they ran out of snacks.....................ugh!! we were never told any info as to why flights were late, no announcements at all.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

Sun, 13 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 45m
Sat, 26 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 14 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: I very much enjoyed the ease of traveling on Porter. It was essentially hassle free. It was also a nice change to have a choice of snacks.

Cons: We experienced a turbulent ride which of course was no fault of Porter. There was no entertainment.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Everything

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.0

Pros: After taking a chance on an airline I had never heard of, we were pleasantly surprised! Although there was a weather related delay, they accommodated us on an earlier flight.

Cons: The plane was a bit loud

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Was offered a earlier flight that was available when we arrived for check in

Cons: I thought I had paid for baggage in advance but obviously there was a glitch in the payment process so HATED the cost for 2 bags. We traveled with 6 other airlines within Europe and none charged this exorbitant amount... NOT VERY PLEASED Check in person wasn’t very pleasant to deal with. I think she was having a bad day!!! All other staff and flight attendants were pleasant and good to deal with.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

Mon, 14 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 34m
Fri, 18 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 5 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: I very much enjoyed the ease of traveling on Porter. It was essentially hassle free. It was also a nice change to have a choice of snacks.

Cons: We experienced a turbulent ride which of course was no fault of Porter. There was no entertainment.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Was offered a earlier flight that was available when we arrived for check in

Cons: I thought I had paid for baggage in advance but obviously there was a glitch in the payment process so HATED the cost for 2 bags. We traveled with 6 other airlines within Europe and none charged this exorbitant amount... NOT VERY PLEASED Check in person wasn’t very pleasant to deal with. I think she was having a bad day!!! All other staff and flight attendants were pleasant and good to deal with.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Pros: The crew was friendly and welcoming

Cons: Our flight was delayed once again. Once we landed our carry on baggage was not given to us right away. We were told to wait for it outside the plane. After waiting, we were told we would have to pick it up at the baggage carousel with the checked luggage. We had to wait over 30 minutes for our carry on luggage.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: No issues. Everything took place on time. The staff were very accommodating and patient with the infants on board

EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: we finally got there

Cons: first time we flew porter air. flight was one hour late, then connecting porter flight was also late. they ran out of snacks.....................ugh!! we were never told any info as to why flights were late, no announcements at all.

Tue, 15 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 45m
Mon, 21 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 7 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: I very much enjoyed the ease of traveling on Porter. It was essentially hassle free. It was also a nice change to have a choice of snacks.

Cons: We experienced a turbulent ride which of course was no fault of Porter. There was no entertainment.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Was offered a earlier flight that was available when we arrived for check in

Cons: I thought I had paid for baggage in advance but obviously there was a glitch in the payment process so HATED the cost for 2 bags. We traveled with 6 other airlines within Europe and none charged this exorbitant amount... NOT VERY PLEASED Check in person wasn’t very pleasant to deal with. I think she was having a bad day!!! All other staff and flight attendants were pleasant and good to deal with.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: No issues. Everything took place on time. The staff were very accommodating and patient with the infants on board

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

Sun, 23 Dec
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 45m
Tue, 8 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 373
Trip: 17 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Thu, 17 Jan
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
YTZ
Toronto Island
6h 09m
Sun, 20 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
10h 55m
C$ 419
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Wed, 16 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 45m
Sat, 26 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 11 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Porter was great, bumped us up to an earlier flight because we had no checked baggage

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Pros: Airport

Cons: Was late going to NewYork and coming home. We were able to get an early flight which was great. Island Aurpirt is wonderful. Price fantastic!

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight

Cons: It was on time for once coming back Toronto

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Everything

EWR
YTZ
Good 7.0

Pros: we finally got there

Cons: first time we flew porter air. flight was one hour late, then connecting porter flight was also late. they ran out of snacks.....................ugh!! we were never told any info as to why flights were late, no announcements at all.

Mon, 14 Jan
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
YTZ
Toronto Island
6h 29m
Wed, 16 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
11h 21m
C$ 423
Trip: 3 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Tue, 29 Jan
LGA
New York LaGuardia
YTZ
Toronto Island
5h 00m
Sun, 3 Feb
YTZ
Toronto Island
LGA
New York LaGuardia
4h 01m
C$ 474
Trip: 6 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 23,328 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
YYZ
HND
Good 7.6

Pros: Generally flight attendant was nice and efficient. Excellent service and

Cons: Food was poor quality. Sometimes water taste like bad tap water. There are very nice crews but some of them are not. Some flight attendant bumped my knee a little when she passed by but didn’t care or noticed.

YVR
YYZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Meals, comfort, polite staff

Cons: Nothing

YYZ
YVR
Good 6.6

Pros: The in flight attendants were very helpful and attentive. Boarding was quick and organized.

Cons: The entertainment system didn’t work well to start, and then stopped working altogether 2 hours into a 5hr flight. The staff tried to fix it and were very apologetic, which made up for it. The seats were a little too hard for me. I was pretty sore by the end of the trip.

YYZ
DUB
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Everything

Cons: Nothing

YUL
DEN
Good 7.0

Cons: Terribly small seats

Thu, 17 Jan
EWR
Newark
YTZ
Toronto Island
1h 34m
Wed, 23 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
EWR
Newark
1h 30m
C$ 230
Trip: 7 days
8.0ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.0 Excellent
Based on 230 reviews
Boarding
7.9
Comfort
7.9
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
6.9
Food
7.8
EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

Pros: Cheaper than other airlines though the flight attendants are really great

Cons: Well you get what you pay Small plane, not as confortable seats

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Porter was great, bumped us up to an earlier flight because we had no checked baggage

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 9.0

Pros: After taking a chance on an airline I had never heard of, we were pleasantly surprised! Although there was a weather related delay, they accommodated us on an earlier flight.

Cons: The plane was a bit loud

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Was offered a earlier flight that was available when we arrived for check in

Cons: I thought I had paid for baggage in advance but obviously there was a glitch in the payment process so HATED the cost for 2 bags. We traveled with 6 other airlines within Europe and none charged this exorbitant amount... NOT VERY PLEASED Check in person wasn’t very pleasant to deal with. I think she was having a bad day!!! All other staff and flight attendants were pleasant and good to deal with.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight.

Tue, 29 Jan
LGA
New York LaGuardia
YTZ
Toronto Island
5h 00m
Sun, 3 Feb
YTZ
Toronto Island
LGA
New York LaGuardia
4h 01m
C$ 474
Trip: 6 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 23,328 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
YYZ
YVR
Good 6.6

Pros: The in flight attendants were very helpful and attentive. Boarding was quick and organized.

Cons: The entertainment system didn’t work well to start, and then stopped working altogether 2 hours into a 5hr flight. The staff tried to fix it and were very apologetic, which made up for it. The seats were a little too hard for me. I was pretty sore by the end of the trip.

MIA
YYZ
Excellent 8.3

Cons: Overhead luggage compartment in business class was poor

YYZ
FCO
Excellent 9.6

Pros: Very smooth flight. Nice 787

Cons: Very cramped no room to move. I can't believe the meals that were served. Very small portions. A slice of bread for breakfast. No butter just dry bread and coffee!!

YYC
YUL
Mediocre 2.0

Cons: I used Kayak to find my ticket and fill out my information (all kayak logos on top of the page and so on). However, when my confirmation email and e-ticket came in, they were issued by Budgetair.com. I had no experience with them and took it to be a reliable website since they were working with Kayak. However, I had to change/cancel my flight because of delayed passport delivery, and this is when everything turned very Ugly! I had to spend an hour over the phone to get connected to an agent with BudgetAir, who disconnected the line within 2 minutes saying: “please hold so I can pull up your information”. This game went on for 6 hours. I tried to connect with the airline directly to make the change, which was not possible since Budgetair had placed a restriction on this ticket. After 6-7 hours, which meant no work for me or lunch because I was sitting behind my desk with a phone on my hand, I got through an agent who was rude and impolite. He took 15 minutes to find flights for the new dates (I did it in 2 minutes on their website), and then told me to pay $315 in extra fess. When I inquired that the prices on your website for the exact same ticket is way cheaper than my original ticket price, he got angry and aggressive. Basically implying that I have no choice to take their offer as is, or let go of my original ticket price of over $2000. Long story short, DO NOT buy from BudgetAir if you like having a peace of mind!

YYZ
LAX
Mediocre 2.6

Pros: Not much

Cons: Lady at check in, Helen, at Pearson was TERRIBLE. No compassion for us travelling with a 2 month old baby, and then booked our seats with united in separate locations with no bassinet. I will never use air Canada Again.

Tue, 29 Jan
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
YTZ
Toronto Island
8h 04m
Wed, 30 Jan
YTZ
Toronto Island
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
8h 25m
C$ 444
Trip: 2 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
*
Prices are per person, are for e–tickets and include all taxes & fees in CAD.

We attempt to get accurate prices, however, prices are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller.
At KAYAK we don’t set the prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We compile tonnes of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we can't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find, on occasion, that certain prices are no longer available.

If you have more questions or if you have a bad price to report to us,
please send us an and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.