ca.kayak.com is also available in French. Voir le site en français.

Find cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island

Find cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island

Round-trip
Economy
Boston (BOS)
Toronto Island
Fri. 5/3
Fri. 12/3
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |
Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Toronto Island

Good to know

Low season

AugustBest time to beat the crowds (2% less expensive on average)

High season

JulyMost popular time to fly (15% more expensive on average)

Average price round-trip

C$ 316(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Good deal round-trip

C$ 117or less

Good deal one-way

C$ 97or less

FAQs for booking New York to Toronto Island flights

How does KAYAK find such low prices on flights from New York to Toronto Island?

How does KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy my flight ticket from New York to Toronto Island?

What is the Hacker Fare option on flights from New York to Toronto Island?

What is KAYAK's "flexible dates" feature and why should I care when looking for a flight from New York to Toronto Island?

Top airlines flying New York to Toronto Island

Scores according to KAYAK customer reviews

7.7
Porter Airlines
Overall score based on 2,710 reviews
7.8
Boarding
7.8
Comfort
8.3
Crew
6.8
Entertainment
7.8
Food
Airline reviews

Pros: "Everything went as planned."
Cons: "USB or power outlets."

Pros: "Yed"
Cons: "If the flight is over Nigara , a brief commentary on Nigara will enthuse the passengers."

Cons: "Not the airline’s fault but we were delayed. That’s the only thing that could have been better"

Pros: "Bunch of crooks gave me the wrong time. Missed my flight"
Cons: "Getting correct to information"

Pros: "Crew perks and helpful staff"
Cons: "Short time between transfers and delay"

Cons: "Canceling flights with no notice and rescheduling made me lose a day"

Pros: "It was nice overall"
Cons: "You are doing the best you can, I guess."

Cons: "The same flight leaving an hour and a half after ours left before ours. I don’t understand how exactly that works the gates were directly next to one another."

Cons: "No carry on baggage fee"

Pros: "Crew was very attentive and pleasant."
Cons: "Stop charging for carry on baggage for outside of Canada flights."

Cons: "Best check in. Allowed earlier flight for a fee which turned out to be 30 minutes delayed but overall excellent check in and crew. Love porter"

Pros: "Everything was alright until I missed my flight to Montreal because the connecting flight was late"
Cons: "If I actually made it to mtl, stuck in Toronto"

Pros: "Snack options, flight attendants"
Cons: "Flight was delayed only a few minutes before initial boarding. The inconsistent communication ‘tween screens, loud speaker, & sent to my phone lead me to wait on line to speak to the person at the gate for clarity-when my turn came he did not help me but some pushy other passenger despite my protest"

Pros: "3 hours delay"
Cons: "Be on time."

Cons: "I was caught off guard to find out at time of check-in that I had to pay a substantial amount for carry-on when I had specifically asked for a carry-on not just a personal item when booking my reservation. I ended up paying more than saving where I could gone with another company.VERY DISAPPOINTED"

Pros: "Very polite"
Cons: "Nothing. This’s my first trip with Porter. Excellent in everything."

Cons: "Boarding was confusing"

Cons: "Flight was very delayed. We got turned around in flight and then ultimately made it. No apologies from crew or porter."

Pros: "Only 15 minutes late and nice new clean plane"
Cons: "No entertainment No lounge No food"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Due to unforeseen circumstances, we arrived at 9:00 for a 10:10 flight, and so were not allowed to try to go through customs to make the flight. When we asked if they could put us on the next flight and we'd pay the $100 plus dollars each to do so, as we realized that we were at fault for arriving late, we were told that they wouldn't do this for us because we had booked through Kayak and not through Porter directly. We were then told that we would have to pay full price for new tickets, over $800. I can't afford to pay another $800 and told them so. I realized we were late, but to be told that they could do nothing for us was horrible. They finally said they'd do it after we told them about our horrendous experience with them on our flight to New York, but then wouldn't let us take our carry on luggage on the flight and charged us a further $60 to put it in the hold. We were then told that they could only get us as far as Toronto, (AFTER we'd paid the extra money) and we'd have to find another way home from there. We live in Ottawa, that's a 6 hour drive, and neither I nor my son drive. It was an absolute nightmare getting back from Toronto, and we didn't get home until 1:00 a.m. Shame on you Kayak and Porter airlines. Our flight to New York was a nightmare (see my other email) and so was our flight home. I know you won't do anything about this and don't care about your customers, but I can assure you that I will be posting as many negative things that I can on social media, and will tell everyone I know never to fly with Porter airlines. Shame on you."

Cons: "Plane too small and noisy"

Cons: "The flight was delayed by 2 hours and I received no notification of this delay. I checked in on the Porter website and provided my email and phone number to notify me of any chances. I took a $100 taxi ride as opposed to the slower $15 train ride thinking the flight was on time. Absolutely not impressed"

Pros: "we finally got there"
Cons: "first time we flew porter air. flight was one hour late, then connecting porter flight was also late. they ran out of snacks.....................ugh!! we were never told any info as to why flights were late, no announcements at all."

Pros: "The flight"
Cons: "It was on time for once coming back Toronto"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Everything"

Pros: "I very much enjoyed the ease of traveling on Porter. It was essentially hassle free. It was also a nice change to have a choice of snacks."
Cons: "We experienced a turbulent ride which of course was no fault of Porter. There was no entertainment."

Pros: "Airport"
Cons: "Was late going to NewYork and coming home. We were able to get an early flight which was great. Island Aurpirt is wonderful. Price fantastic!"

Pros: "Porter was great, bumped us up to an earlier flight because we had no checked baggage"

Pros: "Was offered a earlier flight that was available when we arrived for check in"
Cons: "I thought I had paid for baggage in advance but obviously there was a glitch in the payment process so HATED the cost for 2 bags. We traveled with 6 other airlines within Europe and none charged this exorbitant amount... NOT VERY PLEASED Check in person wasn’t very pleasant to deal with. I think she was having a bad day!!! All other staff and flight attendants were pleasant and good to deal with."

Pros: "No issues. Everything took place on time. The staff were very accommodating and patient with the infants on board"

Pros: "After taking a chance on an airline I had never heard of, we were pleasantly surprised! Although there was a weather related delay, they accommodated us on an earlier flight."
Cons: "The plane was a bit loud"

Pros: "The courteous and helpful nature of both the ground staff and the crew. The Coffee was super."
Cons: "No Complaints whatsoever"

Pros: "Snack selection and free alcohol is good and unique; Porter is great for these short trips."
Cons: "I like the comfortable seats and the 2-2 configuration (no middle seats) but hate the no overhead space."

Pros: "Changed and Billy Bishop Airport in Toronto. Porter has a great little facility there that really treats the passengers well. Both flights to and from Toronto were great."
Cons: "Changed and Billy Bishop Airport in Toronto. Porter has a great little facility there that really treats the passengers well. Both flights to and from Toronto were great."

Pros: "Convenience of the airport location which is steps from downtown Toronto. Friendly crew and descent snacks."
Cons: "Porter flights are almost always delayed. I take them pretty often and they are almost never on time, especially the late afternoon / evenings flights. This time the plane had some problems with AC and was too hot."

Pros: "Staff was pleasant"
Cons: "Missed the concert I went to see. Total disaster."

Pros: "Service was great"

Pros: "Convenience to island airport in Toronto (that’s it)"
Cons: "Delayed flights to and from YTZ-EWR (due to missing crew members) Aircraft felt like it was shaking and floor vibrating the whole time (uncomfortable) Problems boarding, Porter did not check passports and allowed two passengers to board with expired passports so they had to be ejected off the aircraft once boarding was complete and took 40+ mins to find their bags Rude staff on the surround sound and when I asked for a bottle of water I would rather pay LESS and take the UP express to Pearson than EVER fly Porter again"

Pros: "Good service. Thanks"

Pros: "Lounge Wine"

Cons: "Delay"

Pros: "porter gives clients a civilized treatment because of its smallness and amenities"

Pros: "When we went to check in counter we were early enough to get on the flight before ours and we arrived hour and half earlier Make sure your carry on bag is 9kgs or less or you will have to pay to check it"

Pros: "Friendly accommodating crew, always great service"
Cons: "Delays - there are always delays with porter"

Cons: "We've been sitting on the ground in Toronto for an hour. When we landed they said no gates were available, which is moronic."

Pros: "Friendly, nice"
Cons: "Had to wait for luggage"

Cons: "Very bumpyyyyyyyyyyy"

Pros: "They served beverages in REAL glasses, in their waiting room they serve FREE coffee"

Cons: "Seats did not recline at all"

Pros: "New plane!!"
Cons: "No WiFi"

Cons: "Delay"

Pros: "We arrived early in Toronto . Excellent Service"

Pros: "Service was efficient and pleasant. Complementary drinks and snacks were served. This was a nice surprise!"

Pros: "Overall a great experience."

Pros: "As a professional musician, flying with my viola is one of the most nerve wracking experiences, as if it is forced to be checked due to insufficient room for overhead baggage, it could be completely destroyed. As stated in Air Canada's online policy, passengers traveling with musical instruments that fit as carry on baggage are allowed to change to earlier boarding zones. After approaching a staff member with my viola, I wasn't simply assigned an earlier zone, but rather I was allowed to board first. On this principle alone I will be flying Air Canada again. Thank you!!!"

Pros: "Loved the staff. Very friendly. Planes were clean and most of all, got to me my destination. On time!"

Pros: "Good price"
Cons: "Horrible customer care"

Pros: "Delays"
Cons: "Delays"

Cons: "Long delays"

Cons: "Delayed for more than two hours on both the trips to and from Canada. This is a common thing with Air Canada i heard. Flights always get delayed."

Pros: "Once we were up in the air everything was well and good."
Cons: "Massive weather delays at the gate and lack of communication from gate agents."

Pros: "The fact that I called in the a.m. and they rebooked immediately, no charge."

Pros: "No problems."

Pros: "The snack selection is excellent"
Cons: "No complaints"

Cons: "Was not on time, old air craft."

Pros: "Air Canada sucks! Rip off artists. Service is poor and price gauging is rampant"

Pros: "Take off and landing were both smooth and ahead of time. Landed Toronto from New York about 30 minutes early!"
Cons: "Charging for earphones!!!"

Pros: "Flights were on time"
Cons: "Forcing us to check carry on bags, and not very courteous about it."

Pros: "Does not alert passengers they need an ETA before checking in. Waste of time"

Pros: "On time and quick and simple"

Pros: "It was on time and they served drinks."

Cons: "Service"

Cons: "Everything was good"

Pros: "Efficiency, comfort"

Pros: "Quick easy and painless boarding and de boarding. It's been a while since I flew Air Canada and I was pleasantly surprised by the upgrades, including the tinted windows!"

Cons: "Delayed"

Pros: "Everthing was smooth and on time"
Cons: "Nothing specific"

Pros: "Flight was delayed several hours with no compensation given"

Cons: "Cancelled flights and delays."

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "AC Ticket attendants were unbelievably rude."

Cons: "It was canceled"

Pros: "Left on time, arrived on time."

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "The airline failed to mention transit visa rules. Really poor customer service. Irrespective of what time of the day you call, the average wait time is 30 min. Who can wait for 30 min to receive his/her call. That's stupid for a premium air line. Even when someone answered they failed to provide a solution and were unsympathetic to my cause"

Pros: "Overall good. A bad delay and boarding process. I can't fill out the above rating cause my computer dos'nt let me."

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Cancelled, terrible service, cancelled last minute, no reasonable options for rebooking, not enough staff, disorganized section at airport, rudest security ever."

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Cancelled flights, delays, no refund option so I had to wait 15hrs to get to a 1 hrs destination. Then they lost my luggage so my mini weekend away turned into a disaster. I basically wasted $1,000 for a nightmare trip. If they would've just issued a refund in the beginning I would've been fine w the cancelation."

Cons: "Flights get cancelled or delayed all the time so that's not what was so upsetting. It was the way we were informed about these delays. The staff were jest rude, making a bad experience even worse. Then they lost my bags, couldn't track them, couldn't tell me where they were. And I was flying out to another country for a tour next day so that was very inconvenient. I won't be flying with this airline again. They don't know what good customer service is."

Pros: "on time"

Pros: "The staff was generally helpful and pleasant."
Cons: "The airport kiosks were down save one. This created unnecessarily longer wait times for everyone,me specially those that were only looking to get a printed Boarding Pass."

Cons: "Good"

Pros: "Everyone was nice and the seating area had room."

Cons: "It got cancelled and the service was horrific"

Cons: "My daughter got destroyed by a cup of coffee a passenger behind her was holding when turbulence struck quiet bad,neither he or the airline apologizes for either."

Pros: "We arrived ontime."

Cons: "LONG DELETED !!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Cons: "Long time till take off."

Pros: "it was on time landed a few minutes early stewerdess were very nice"

Cons: "They charged us 25 dollars for a carry on bag which was unfair. They didn't charge anyone else. When I came back I was not charged. I would like a refund. The people were very rude! I take that bag on trips weekly. I should have not been charged."

Cons: "I called and confirmed a special meal 40 hours in advance. They said they had no request form me and gave me fruit,"

Read more about Porter Airlines
COVID-19 information

Safety measures for airlines flying from New York to Toronto Island

Airlines flying from New York to Toronto Island have enacted additional safety measures and adjusted policies to better accommodate travellers. Policies vary by airline.

Heightened sanitation

Daily cleaning, installation of cabin HEPA filters on flights from New York to Toronto Island

Mandatory masks

Masks required on board, masks provided on flights from New York to Toronto Island

Social distancing seating

Middle seats unavailable to book on flights from New York to Toronto Island

Pre-flight testing

Testing for antibodies, testing for symptoms for flights from New York to Toronto Island

Book cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island

Recent round-trip flight deals

7/8
Sat.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 45m
EWR - YTZ
14/8
Sat.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
14/4
Wed.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
21/4
Wed.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
3h 53m
YTZ - EWR
11/5
Tue.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 45m
LGA - YTZ
18/5
Tue.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 40m
YTZ - LGA
28/5
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 45m
EWR - YTZ
2/6
Wed.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
28/5
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 39m
EWR - YTZ
2/6
Wed.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
14/4
Wed.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
21/4
Wed.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
13/4
Tue.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
20/4
Tue.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
5h 53m
YTZ - EWR
2/4
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
5/4
Mon.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 31m
YTZ - EWR
10/4
Sat.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
4h 53m
YTZ - EWR
11/5
Tue.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 10m
EWR - YTZ
18/5
Tue.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 55m
YTZ - EWR
6/4
Tue.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
17/4
Sat.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
11/8
Wed.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 39m
EWR - YTZ
13/8
Fri.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
3h 55m
YTZ - EWR
31/3
Wed.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
4/4
Sun.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
19/4
Mon.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
26/4
Mon.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
5h 53m
YTZ - EWR
9/8
Mon.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 55m
LGA - YTZ
11/8
Wed.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 50m
YTZ - LGA
31/3
Wed.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 45m
EWR - YTZ
4/4
Sun.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
2/4
Fri.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
4h 40m
EWR - YTZ
5/4
Mon.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
29/8
Sun.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 55m
LGA - YTZ
10/9
Fri.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 55m
YTZ - LGA
7/4
Wed.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
11/4
Sun.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
1/4
Thu.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
4h 40m
EWR - YTZ
8/4
Thu.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
Show more results

Recent one-way flight deals

6/4
Tue.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 40m
EWR - YTZ
30/3
Tue.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
29/3
Mon.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
40h 12m
EWR - YTZ
14/5
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 45m
EWR - YTZ
9/4
Fri.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 40m
EWR - YTZ
9/4
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 38m
EWR - YTZ
28/3
Sun.
1 stop
Air Canada
95h 40m
EWR - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
11h 04m
LGA - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
17h 59m
EWR - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
17h 59m
EWR - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
42h 24m
EWR - YTZ
6/4
Tue.
2 stops
Air Canada
31h 20m
EWR - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
12h 41m
LGA - YTZ
16/4
Fri.
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
42h 24m
EWR - YTZ
18/4
Sun.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
10h 21m
LGA - YTZ
6/4
Tue.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
5h 29m
JFK - YTZ
18/4
Sun.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
34h 10m
LGA - YTZ
Show more results
-
1
  • Round-trip
  • One-way
  • Multi-city
  • Trip Builder
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
  • Multiple
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First