ca.kayak.com is also available in French. Voir le site en français.

Find cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island

NYC - YTZ

Find cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Toronto Island

Round-trip
Economy
New York (NYC)
Toronto Island
Sat. 17/4
Sat. 24/4
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Good to know

Low season

AugustBest time to beat the crowds (65% less expensive on average)

High season

JanuaryMost popular time to fly (30% more expensive on average)

Average price round-trip

C$ 326(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Good deal round-trip

C$ 341or less

Good deal one-way

C$ 175or less

When to book flights from New York to Toronto Island

Estimated round-trip price
Average price per month
Flight prices as travel date approaches

Top tips for finding a cheap flight

  • Looking for a cheap flight? 25% of our users found flights on this route for C$ 175 or less one-way and C$ 341 or less round-trip.
  • The cheapest flight from New York to Toronto Island was found, on average, 74 days before departure.
  • Book at least 3 weeks before departure in order to get a below-average price.
  • High season is considered to be December, January and February. The cheapest month to fly is August.

FAQs for booking New York to Toronto Island flights

How long does a flight from New York to Toronto Island take?

Which airlines provide the cheapest flights from New York to Toronto Island?

What’s the cheapest day of the week to fly from New York to Toronto Island?

How does KAYAK find such low prices on flights from New York to Toronto Island?

How does KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy my flight ticket from New York to Toronto Island?

What is the Hacker Fare option on flights from New York to Toronto Island?

What is KAYAK's "flexible dates" feature and why should I care when looking for a flight from New York to Toronto Island?

Top airlines flying New York to Toronto Island

Scores according to KAYAK customer reviews

7.7
Porter Airlines
Overall score based on 2,710 reviews
7.8
Boarding
7.8
Comfort
8.3
Crew
6.8
Entertainment
7.8
Food
Airline reviews

Pros: "Yed"
Cons: "If the flight is over Nigara , a brief commentary on Nigara will enthuse the passengers."

Cons: "Not the airline’s fault but we were delayed. That’s the only thing that could have been better"

Pros: "Crew perks and helpful staff"
Cons: "Short time between transfers and delay"

Cons: "Canceling flights with no notice and rescheduling made me lose a day"

Cons: "No carry on baggage fee"

Pros: "Crew was very attentive and pleasant."
Cons: "Stop charging for carry on baggage for outside of Canada flights."

Cons: "Best check in. Allowed earlier flight for a fee which turned out to be 30 minutes delayed but overall excellent check in and crew. Love porter"

Pros: "The crew was very nice, and I love the complimentary craft beer!"

Pros: "3 hours delay"
Cons: "Be on time."

Cons: "I was caught off guard to find out at time of check-in that I had to pay a substantial amount for carry-on when I had specifically asked for a carry-on not just a personal item when booking my reservation. I ended up paying more than saving where I could gone with another company.VERY DISAPPOINTED"

Pros: "Very polite"
Cons: "Nothing. This’s my first trip with Porter. Excellent in everything."

Cons: "Boarding was confusing"

Pros: "Only 15 minutes late and nice new clean plane"
Cons: "No entertainment No lounge No food"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Due to unforeseen circumstances, we arrived at 9:00 for a 10:10 flight, and so were not allowed to try to go through customs to make the flight. When we asked if they could put us on the next flight and we'd pay the $100 plus dollars each to do so, as we realized that we were at fault for arriving late, we were told that they wouldn't do this for us because we had booked through Kayak and not through Porter directly. We were then told that we would have to pay full price for new tickets, over $800. I can't afford to pay another $800 and told them so. I realized we were late, but to be told that they could do nothing for us was horrible. They finally said they'd do it after we told them about our horrendous experience with them on our flight to New York, but then wouldn't let us take our carry on luggage on the flight and charged us a further $60 to put it in the hold. We were then told that they could only get us as far as Toronto, (AFTER we'd paid the extra money) and we'd have to find another way home from there. We live in Ottawa, that's a 6 hour drive, and neither I nor my son drive. It was an absolute nightmare getting back from Toronto, and we didn't get home until 1:00 a.m. Shame on you Kayak and Porter airlines. Our flight to New York was a nightmare (see my other email) and so was our flight home. I know you won't do anything about this and don't care about your customers, but I can assure you that I will be posting as many negative things that I can on social media, and will tell everyone I know never to fly with Porter airlines. Shame on you."

Pros: "Hassle free"
Cons: "Since it's a small bombardier the leg space is pretty restricted.. only adjustable for short flights"

Cons: "Plane too small and noisy"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Everything"

Pros: "Porter was great, bumped us up to an earlier flight because we had no checked baggage"

Pros: "No issues. Everything took place on time. The staff were very accommodating and patient with the infants on board"

Pros: "After taking a chance on an airline I had never heard of, we were pleasantly surprised! Although there was a weather related delay, they accommodated us on an earlier flight."
Cons: "The plane was a bit loud"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Wasn’t warned on website about applying for ETA. Airline didn’t accommodate me in this situation and proceed to charge me $100 to change my flight."

Pros: "The courteous and helpful nature of both the ground staff and the crew. The Coffee was super."
Cons: "No Complaints whatsoever"

Pros: "Snack selection and free alcohol is good and unique; Porter is great for these short trips."
Cons: "I like the comfortable seats and the 2-2 configuration (no middle seats) but hate the no overhead space."

Pros: "Changed and Billy Bishop Airport in Toronto. Porter has a great little facility there that really treats the passengers well. Both flights to and from Toronto were great."
Cons: "Changed and Billy Bishop Airport in Toronto. Porter has a great little facility there that really treats the passengers well. Both flights to and from Toronto were great."

Pros: "Once our plane finally got there the crew and people working the desk were super efficient and concentrated on getting us on our way ASAP."
Cons: "We were 6 hours delayed. The weather was bad so it wasn’t anyone’s fault. It just sucked."

Pros: "Staff was pleasant"
Cons: "Missed the concert I went to see. Total disaster."

Pros: "Convenience to island airport in Toronto (that’s it)"
Cons: "Delayed flights to and from YTZ-EWR (due to missing crew members) Aircraft felt like it was shaking and floor vibrating the whole time (uncomfortable) Problems boarding, Porter did not check passports and allowed two passengers to board with expired passports so they had to be ejected off the aircraft once boarding was complete and took 40+ mins to find their bags Rude staff on the surround sound and when I asked for a bottle of water I would rather pay LESS and take the UP express to Pearson than EVER fly Porter again"

Pros: "Good service. Thanks"

Pros: "I have flown on Porter numerous time but this was the first for my family. They enjoyed the Porter lounge and convenience of flying from the Toronto island right into EWR. We were able to take the NJ Train right to Penn Station (NYC) faster than any taxi."

Pros: "Either my mistake or a computer glitch gave me a ticket for an evening flight when I was looking for a morning flight. I was able to avoid switching fees by showing up at the airport for the first flight, and I was able to be seated comfortably. The staff at the check in was very nice and helpful. There is no entertainment so I gave that a one. On the short flight that I was on there was a choice of snacks, I chose almonds, thank you very much for the almonds and beverage. Happy travels, everyone!"
Cons: "They wanted me to check my carry on which could easily have fit under the seat in front of me."

Pros: "Lounge Wine"

Pros: "Why would you go any other way? Dependable service, complimentary in-flight wine, the world's best shortbread cookies, breeze through customs and the arrival gate is within walking distance of your hotel."
Cons: "Are you kidding?"

Cons: "Delay"

Pros: "porter gives clients a civilized treatment because of its smallness and amenities"

Pros: "Great service! Attentive staff. Fabulous free lounges with drinks and snacks. Cappuccino in real cups in Toronto. Free wine and beer on flights. Real glasses on flights and in Toronto lounge. Gate agents were friendly and so helpful. Nrwark had a nice smaller lounge. Lots of legroom on flights."
Cons: "You have to be aware that these are props, so flights do get delayed or cancelled due to weather. Both of our flights were delayed. But they were very up front about it. Also put us on earlier flights automatically which was nice."

Pros: "When we went to check in counter we were early enough to get on the flight before ours and we arrived hour and half earlier Make sure your carry on bag is 9kgs or less or you will have to pay to check it"

Cons: "Only 1 Agent at check in. Took a while to get through the line. Flight delayed."

Cons: "We've been sitting on the ground in Toronto for an hour. When we landed they said no gates were available, which is moronic."

Pros: "Friendly, nice"
Cons: "Had to wait for luggage"

Cons: "Very bumpyyyyyyyyyyy"

Cons: "Seats did not recline at all"

Pros: "My trip was excellent.Coulb not ask more. Thank you."

Cons: "After my flight with porter airline my souvenirs that were glass were smashed.. I have been on many flights around the states with those exact souvenirs and nothing. I don't think they treat your bags with care at all"

Cons: "Delays"

Cons: "We were unable to rebook or use flights as s credit so when plans changed even though it was months away we were just out the money"

Pros: "Overall great experience after a hectic weekend in New York City! Very relaxing, check-in to Uber"

Pros: "Pretty much everything was good on the flight and afterwards, even with a delay it was a pleasant experience...."
Cons: "The only problem we're the gate agents in Newark, they disappeared for 20 minutes and no one was at the gate even after the original boarding time had come and gone. When she finally came in there was neither an apology or even an acknowledgement that I was there. 5 min after after she Arrived I had to get her to stop what she was doin to ask if si would make my other flight , all she said was " not sure" no sign of even wanting to help. She was awful"

Pros: "Small airport"

Pros: "on schedule"
Cons: "I arrived early enough to possible catch the previous flight, but the gate attendant didn't want to be bothered with my request."

Cons: "Being delayed 10 hours"

Cons: "nothing"

Pros: "Well located at LGA (NYC) with it own section of gate doors that is just Air Canada. Multiple flights leaving where EXTREMELY delayed, the staff put on their thinking caps, they started putting people on standby so most customers leave on an earlier flight! I was located in an extra room chair (free) due to this adjustment of delayed flights and was a great experience."
Cons: "It’s the usual BS that you get at airports....TSA is always insane but honestly it was better than I thought l."

Pros: "My passport wasn’t signed and I couldn’t locate my pen. The agent had a pen in front of him and refused to let me use it. He informed me that his pen is a personal item and that I need to learn a lesson that all travelors should have a pen handy. He proceeded to move me off he line and board additional passangers."
Cons: "My passport wasn’t signed and I couldn’t locate my pen. The agent had a pen in front of him and refused to let me use it. He informed me that his pen is a personal item and that I need to learn a lesson that all travelors should have a pen handy. He proceeded to move me off he line and board additional passangers."

Pros: "New plane!!"
Cons: "No WiFi"

Pros: "Quiet"
Cons: "Nothing"

Pros: "The crew on the flights was great over all but everyone else that we encountered seemed confused, rude, and/or uninterested in helping anyone."
Cons: "Multiple times on the trip we were told one thing only to be told the complete opposite by someone else a short time later. No two teams seemed to have any clue what the other was doing and there seemed to be no overarching strategy or systems in place company wide. We have flown with a baby many times on my airlines and this time was by far the worst- they do not seem like a family friendly airline at all."

Pros: "We arrived early in Toronto . Excellent Service"

Pros: "Service was efficient and pleasant. Complementary drinks and snacks were served. This was a nice surprise!"

Pros: "Overall a great experience."

Pros: "Good price"
Cons: "Horrible customer care"

Pros: "Delays"
Cons: "Delays"

Pros: "That at least, the plane eventually did take off and landed safely."
Cons: "Fly time each way from NY to Toronto is approx an hour but they added an extra hour of a delay going and and an hour and a half delay further on the flight back home."

Cons: "What a mess. Every DELTA flight I have been on in recent months has had terrible delay issues - I'm cancelling my credit card."

Pros: "I prefer to fly Air Canada over the other airlines that fly between New York and Toronto because of the comfort and cleanliness in the aircraft and pleasant service."

Cons: "Long delays"

Cons: "Delayed for more than two hours on both the trips to and from Canada. This is a common thing with Air Canada i heard. Flights always get delayed."

Pros: "Once we were up in the air everything was well and good."
Cons: "Massive weather delays at the gate and lack of communication from gate agents."

Pros: "The fact that I called in the a.m. and they rebooked immediately, no charge."

Pros: "No problems."

Pros: "The snack selection is excellent"
Cons: "No complaints"

Cons: "Was not on time, old air craft."

Pros: "Air Canada sucks! Rip off artists. Service is poor and price gauging is rampant"

Pros: "Im not impressed with air canada. Every time I fly with them there is ALWAYS a delay. I understand that they cant help weather. But when your flight gets delayed over an hour due to their own computer system failing on the way to newyork and to not be compinsated at all its not acceptable. Even on my way home from newyork we were supose to board at 7:55pm and ended up boarding at 9:40pm. they decided to pick and choose people to be boarded on the earlier flight that was right before mine. Not at all fair. I used my whole 30 minutes free wifi (that cuts in and out constantly)before we found out about the delay then I was left with nothing. Not cool when you cant contact anyone. Also REALLY ANNOYING. and the staff are rude if you ask them anything. Then on the plane i wasted 5 bucks trying to buy wifi since you guys dont even have it on your planes for free like delta does. Even then you pay for the worst wifi on the planet where your messages take a half hour to go through and over my whole hour and 10 minute flight i had 3 messages because of your horrible gogo wifi. Waste of money. Overall this whole air canada experience made me want to rip my hair out and stressed me out to the point that I dont want to fly again. I will more then likely not fly with you guys if it can be avoided"

Pros: "Take off and landing were both smooth and ahead of time. Landed Toronto from New York about 30 minutes early!"
Cons: "Charging for earphones!!!"

Pros: "Does not alert passengers they need an ETA before checking in. Waste of time"

Pros: "On time and quick and simple"

Pros: "It was on time and they served drinks."

Cons: "Service"

Cons: "Everything was good"

Pros: "Efficiency, comfort"

Pros: "Quick easy and painless boarding and de boarding. It's been a while since I flew Air Canada and I was pleasantly surprised by the upgrades, including the tinted windows!"

Cons: "Delayed"

Pros: "Everthing was smooth and on time"
Cons: "Nothing specific"

Pros: "Flight was delayed several hours with no compensation given"

Cons: "Cancelled flights and delays."

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "AC Ticket attendants were unbelievably rude."

Pros: "Left on time, arrived on time."

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Cancelled flights, delays, no refund option so I had to wait 15hrs to get to a 1 hrs destination. Then they lost my luggage so my mini weekend away turned into a disaster. I basically wasted $1,000 for a nightmare trip. If they would've just issued a refund in the beginning I would've been fine w the cancelation."

Pros: "on time"

Cons: "Good"

Pros: "Everyone was nice and the seating area had room."

Cons: "It got cancelled and the service was horrific"

Cons: "My daughter got destroyed by a cup of coffee a passenger behind her was holding when turbulence struck quiet bad,neither he or the airline apologizes for either."

Pros: "We arrived ontime."

Cons: "LONG DELETED !!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Cons: "Long time till take off."

Pros: "it was on time landed a few minutes early stewerdess were very nice"

Cons: "2 hour delay"

Cons: "They charged us 25 dollars for a carry on bag which was unfair. They didn't charge anyone else. When I came back I was not charged. I would like a refund. The people were very rude! I take that bag on trips weekly. I should have not been charged."

Read more about Porter Airlines
COVID-19 information

Safety measures for airlines flying from New York to Toronto Island

Airlines flying from New York to Toronto Island have enacted additional safety measures and adjusted policies to better accommodate travellers. Policies vary by airline.

Heightened sanitation

Daily cleaning, installation of cabin HEPA filters on flights from New York to Toronto Island

Mandatory masks

Masks required on board, masks provided on flights from New York to Toronto Island

Social distancing seating

Middle seats unavailable to book on flights from New York to Toronto Island

Pre-flight testing

Testing for antibodies, testing for symptoms for flights from New York to Toronto Island

Book cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island

Recent round-trip flight deals

30/7
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 29m
EWR - YTZ
1/8
Sun.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
11/9
Sat.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 00m
LGA - YTZ
18/9
Sat.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 05m
YTZ - LGA
6/8
Fri.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
15/8
Sun.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
4h 55m
YTZ - EWR
3/8
Tue.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 55m
LGA - YTZ
12/8
Thu.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 50m
YTZ - LGA
15/7
Thu.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 39m
EWR - YTZ
20/7
Tue.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
12/8
Thu.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 38m
EWR - YTZ
17/8
Tue.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 25m
YTZ - EWR
22/5
Sat.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 13m
LGA - YTZ
26/5
Wed.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 32m
YTZ - LGA
3/9
Fri.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
6h 10m
EWR - YTZ
6/9
Mon.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
1/9
Wed.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
6/9
Mon.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
6/9
Mon.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 55m
LGA - YTZ
15/9
Wed.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 40m
YTZ - LGA
25/6
Fri.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
30/6
Wed.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
5h 55m
YTZ - EWR
12/9
Sun.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
15/9
Wed.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
18/7
Sun.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 45m
LGA - YTZ
24/7
Sat.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 55m
YTZ - LGA
21/6
Mon.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 45m
EWR - YTZ
25/6
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
21/5
Fri.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
4h 18m
EWR - YTZ
26/5
Wed.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
1/10
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
3/10
Sun.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
14/6
Mon.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
4h 03m
EWR - YTZ
22/6
Tue.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
26/5
Wed.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 13m
LGA - YTZ
31/5
Mon.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 32m
YTZ - LGA
6/8
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 39m
EWR - YTZ
25/9
Sat.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
13/6
Sun.
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
4h 03m
EWR - YTZ
23/6
Wed.
direct
Multiple Airlines
1h 30m
YTZ - EWR
Show more results

Recent one-way flight deals

19/7
Mon.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 55m
LGA - YTZ
1/7
Thu.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
5/6
Sat.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
16/8
Mon.
1 stop
Air Canada
3h 55m
LGA - YTZ
4/6
Fri.
direct
Porter Airlines
1h 40m
EWR - YTZ
1/7
Thu.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 10m
LGA - YTZ
1/7
Thu.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 10m
EWR - YTZ
5/6
Sat.
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
19h 46m
EWR - YTZ
1/6
Tue.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 03m
EWR - YTZ
1/6
Tue.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 13m
LGA - YTZ
5/6
Sat.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 03m
EWR - YTZ
5/6
Sat.
1 stop
Air Canada
4h 13m
LGA - YTZ
19/7
Mon.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
23h 01m
LGA - YTZ
24/8
Tue.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
36h 28m
LGA - YTZ
6/6
Sun.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
38h 37m
EWR - YTZ
6/6
Sun.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
36h 30m
LGA - YTZ
5/6
Sat.
2 stops
Air Canada
9h 35m
EWR - YTZ
5/6
Sat.
2 stops
Air Canada
9h 35m
EWR - YTZ
30/7
Fri.
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
37h 22m
LGA - YTZ
23/7
Fri.
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
36h 29m
LGA - YTZ
Show more results
-
1
  • Round-trip
  • One-way
  • Multi-city
  • Trip Builder
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
  • Multiple
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First