Book Advantage car rentals in New York

New York, NY, United States
7 Jul — 14 Jul
Same drop-off
New York, NY, United States
Thu 7/7
Thu 14/7
Driver's age:

Reviews for Advantage in New York

Overall Rating5.1 OkayBased on 372 reviews
Value for money

Recent reviews

Traveler rating
Find reviews that mention:
Pros:Pick staff were friendly but at drop off the manager was disrespectful and rude. We need to use a restroom and the manager refused, saying that since we dropped off the car we were no longer customers and could care less if we needed to use the restroom. I was shocked at that response.Cons:The vehicle was dirty and had a sticky film in the inside of the driver side window. They didn’t have our reserved car class and we were given a minivan. Plus the utter disrespect and rudeness at drop off was unacceptable.Reviewed 25 May 2020
review fromkayak
Cons:Everything was greatReviewed 6 May 2020
review fromkayak
Pros:Staff was very helpful.Cons:Car had some wear & tear.. the price could have been lower to reflect the condition of the car.Reviewed 4 May 2020
review fromkayak
Cons:Car was damaged in all 4 quarters at pickup. Also had a nail in one tire. They wouldn't answer the phone when I called to report it 5 min after pickup.Reviewed 25 Apr. 2020
review fromkayak
Cons:I was charged for a car I didn’t use. And now I cannot get a refund now matter how hard I try.Reviewed 24 Apr. 2020
review fromkayak
Pros:Location did not have car when I arrived, had to wait for about four hours at rental car location for a car. Once I picked up the car is smelled heavily of marijuana smoke, no discount was offered. Rental car location did not clean car, I had to disinfect the car myself. When I tried to return the car I called the location multiple times and they did not pick up, instead they sent me an email address to contact to contact the agency, I emails and have not heard anything back yet (it’s been two days). Horrible experience, I will not be using advantage again.Reviewed 22 Mar. 2020
review fromkayak
Pros:Pick up and drop off was indeed super easy.Cons:I normally don't opt for prepaid fuel but when the question of prepaid fuel came up I said that would be convenient since I didn't know of a gas station nearby (I have never rented a car from JFK Airport before). It turns out there is a gas station one block away from the rental drop off. It could not have been easier to get gas. Seems like the nice guy at the desk could have pointed that out.Reviewed 21 Jan. 2020
review fromkayak
Cons:They had no cars. We had to call another company while we were waiting there for over 40 minutes with no cars in sight and others in line to get cars ahead of us.Reviewed 9 Dec. 2019
review fromkayak
Pros:Staff very friendly and helpful on both pickup and drop offCons:Car was in very poor condition (breaks very worn, windows did not function properly, poor wipers, car smelled like smoke)Reviewed 25 Nov. 2019
review fromkayak
Cons:Google Translation: When I arrived at the rental, I was told that because I was driving less than 25, it cost me $ 560 instead of the 130 I ordered and paid - even though I specifically wrote in the reservation that I was 23 !!!Reviewed 29 Oct. 2019
review fromkayak
Pros:The car was very comfortable.Cons:Customer service at pickup.Reviewed 25 Oct. 2019
review fromkayak
Pros:Price was good. EZ Pass expensive though.Cons:More customer service people at the counter.Reviewed 18 Oct. 2019
review fromkayak

Where can I find Advantage car rentals in New York?

90-05 25th Ave, Advantage car rentals


90-05 25th Ave


Friday05:00 - 23:59
Monday05:00 - 23:59
Wednesday05:00 - 23:59
Tuesday05:00 - 23:59
Thursday05:00 - 23:59
Saturday05:00 - 23:59
Sunday05:00 - 23:59


+1 718 424 8504


318 Federal Circle


Friday00:00 - 23:59
Monday00:00 - 23:59
Wednesday00:00 - 23:59
Tuesday00:00 - 23:59
Thursday00:00 - 23:59
Saturday00:00 - 23:59
Sunday00:00 - 23:59


+1 718 632 1632

Good to know

Most popular car type


Average price

C$ 92/day

Good deal

C$ 73/day

Top tips for renting a car from Advantage in New York

  • 25% of our users found rental cars from Advantage in New York for C$ 73 or less
  • Intermediate rental cars from Advantage in New York are around 58% cheaper than other car types, on average

FAQs about renting a car from Advantage in New York